Time to settle this once and for all

Time to settle this once and for all.

Attached: John vs. Arthur.png (1200x675, 1.02M)

Attached: 10471048.jpg (1600x898, 207.8K)

i've never played the first rdr, so imma say arthur

i'm trans btw if that matters

Inb4 Arthur cuck copypasta

Uncle

John, he beat up Arthur over Abigail

John by far. He has so many memorable lines in RDR1, I can barely remember any for Arthur.

based

Attached: red.jpg (480x420, 25.4K)

Hard to say, but I like Arthur more. They both fit in the stories of their games perfectly tho.

John because he goes through an actual character arc within both games while as much as I like Arthur, he only becomes an interesting character when he finds out he's going to die

2 is better than 1

no current gen patch = no buy
simple as

we just had a fucking thread about this shit ""argument"". It's a fucking non issue, we're not fucking fromdrone kiddie fans who fight over which sequel is better. There is no need to have this discussion 3x a day.

Arthur is a better gunslinger if that's what this vs is about

John married a whore.
That is all you need to know.

>because he goes through an actual character arc
you know who had an arc?
Noah!

better at sucking dicks

WE

ALL

HAD

SEX

John feels like a real person
Arthur is a good character
Red is the best video game character

Red wins

Based Juarez enjoyer.