CD is better than 2 by a fucking long shot
2 has one of the worst quality drop offs in a Sonic game
>literally everything after Mystic Cave is trash but people still pretend it’s flawless and say “muh skill”
CD is better than 2 by a fucking long shot
Aaron Rivera
Brandon Adams
Sonic 2 is good until the end of Metropolis (essentially the end of the game). Consistent and strong.
Sonic 1 struggles after GHZ, but sustains enjoyability.
Sonic CD doesn't even start off good.
2>1>CD
Brody Murphy
Everyone who likes "exploration" in Sonic is a major autist. If you want to "explore," try going outside.
David Garcia
Everyone who loves speed is retarded. You want to hold down a button and go fast? Drive a car
Wyatt Wood
2 is the best game in the series. Followed by S&K, Sonic 3, Sonic CD and Sonic 1 in that order.
I'm right and you're wrong.
Austin Brown
>2 over 3 or K
Why do people lie like this?
Nathan Wilson
Cd sucks
Lucas Cooper
>Why do people lie like this?
I'm a truth teller. It is one of the best sequels of all time. It's the best Sonic game. Fact.
Jonathan Brooks
To be contrarians or its game they grew up with same way some fags swear that smb3 is better than world
Jaxson Cook
It doesn't go both ways. Exploration is how children interact with games. If you're playing a platformer and you hand the controller to a young child, if they can even move, they'll probably just end up wandering the map, not even attempting to engage with skill-driven aspect of the game. I remember doing the same when I was young as well. It's fine when you're a kid, but it's not as cute when autistic manchildren do it. Not even modern open world games can hold the attention of an adult for a long time. "Exploring" a Sonic map is an extremely shallow and time-wasting experience.
Hudson Lee
2 is better than 3 or S&K individually. But 3&K as one game is better than 2.
Also 3 was tainted by a pedophile. Half-pipe is better than Blue Spheres. 2 has a better soundtrack. I will say that I love 3's boss battle music for Robotnik.
Anthony Butler
>"Exploring" a Sonic map is an extremely shallow and time-wasting experience
But user, there may be ring boxes, shields, or 1ups to find! Plus exploring hidden routes helps you to learn shortcuts for when you want to speedrun.
Charles Cooper
If the goal of exploration is to improve at the skill-driven aspect of the game, that's fine. If exploration itself is the goal, like in Sonic CD, it's just an objectively worse kind of Sonic game, because it's not really what Sonic excels at.
Ryder Stewart
>3 was tainted by a pedophile
First off, the man made Thriller so back to resetera with that mentality
Second off
>2 has a better soundtrack
You baited me
David Brown
Sonic 3 is the best Sonic and if you disagree you are being a contrarian.
Sebastian Nguyen
For me, it's the Adventure games and Heroes, even though Heroes is objectively not that good.
t. 1999 bro
Jason Sanders
I think Sonic 3 handled exploration brilliantly.
>put special rings in each zone to encourage exploring
>different pathways for all characters that all feel like they give you speed despite the verticality of most levels
>even if you have the chaos emeralds finding special rings still reward you with 50 rings for SS now or later if you hold on to them, or extra time being Super Sonic
>can find hidden continues or elemental shields that help you out in the level design
I love CD but yeah, outside of the past badnik machines, there’s zero incentive to explore the present or future
Nicholas Baker
Aaron James
IMAGINE BEING SO...
Christopher Baker
Holy FUCK I haven’t had one of these since I was a kid, I’m going shopping tomorrow I need to try this shit again
Also
Mainline 2D
3&K>Mania>CD>1>2
I don’t like Sonic 2
Mainline 3D
SA1>Unleashed>Generations>SA2>Heroes>who gives a shit
Adrian Thompson
>Half-pipe is better than Blue Spheres
Andrew Cook
>Redditbob
Go back
Camden Wood
Sonic CD is pure rubbish.
Ryder Richardson
>no Super Monkey Ball 2
>no Kim Possible
>No Totally Spies or Code Lyoko
Wyd
Adam Walker
sonic 1 starts great but is kinda meh
sonic 2 is great
sonic 3&k is amazing
sonic cd is interesting but is kinda meh
I just wish knuckles chaotix was good