>Steam reviews 1. Dark Souls 3 & Sekiro (93%) 2. Elden Ring (90%) 3. Dark Souls 1 (87%) 4. Dark Souls 2 (85%) [Bloodborne is unranked in Steam]
>Google reviews 1. Bloodborne (4.8 stars) 2. Dark Souls 1 (4.5 stars) 3. Elden Ring & Sekiro (4.3 stars) 4. Dark Souls 3 (4.0 stars) 5. Dark Souls 2 (3.8 stars)
>Metacritic user reviews 1. Bloodborne (8.9/10) 2. Dark Souls 3 (8.6/10) 3. Sekiro (8.5/10) 4. Dark Souls 1 (8.1/10) 5. Elden Ring (7.9/10) 6. Dark Souls 2 (7.7/10)
>Metacritic journalist reviews 1. Elden Ring (96/100) 2. Bloodborne (92/100) 3. Sekiro (90/100) 4. Dark Souls 3 (89/100) 5. Dark Souls 2 (87/100) 6. Dark Souls 1 (84/100)
>Confirmed sales 1. Elden Ring (~15 million so far) 2. Dark Souls 3 (10 million) 3. Dark Souls 1 (6 million) 4. Sekiro (5 million) 5. Dark Souls 2 (2,5 million) 6. Bloodborne (2 million)
>Confirmed completion rate 1. Dark Souls 3 (48%) 2. Elden Ring (46%) 3. Dark Souls 1 (45%) 4. Bloodborne (44%) 5. Dark Souls 2 (41%) 6. Sekiro (Combined score [Average placement in all rankings] 1. Dark Souls 3 & Elden Ring (2,3) 2. Bloodborne (2,8) 3. Dark Souls 1 (3,0) 4. Sekiro (3,3) 5. Dark Souls 2 (5,0)
=> Dark Souls 3 and Elden Ring are most widely popular Soulslike games, with a combination of high sales, decent reviews and high completion rates. => Bloodborne is the best reviewed once sales are ignored. Few players played Bloodborne, but almost everyone liked it. => Dark Souls 2 is the least popular by a wide margin, across many factors. => Sekiro is amongst the best reviewed games, but has a shockingly low completion rate and average sales.
The only thing that matters is your own rankings, and it only matters to you. Here is mine: >Bloodborne >Dark Souls >Demon's Souls >Dark Souls 3 >Dark Souls 2 >Elden Ring I have yet to play Sekiro, I am waiting for it to go on sale (PS5 Digital).
I'm 100% sure bloodborne has sold way more than that. They just haven't updated in years, pretty sure they're not even taking digital sales. That being said i bought the game three times and all of my copies were secondhand, so maybe there is something to it. But definitely a lot more people have played the game than the physical sales let on.
Easton Reed
>Sekiro
William Mitchell
>i bought the game three times do snoys really?
Luke Hill
its a snoy exclusive, poor sales were calculated in from the start
Landon Turner
>that Sekiro completion rate Fucking kek, people really did get filtered cause they can't summon. Also this whole ranking is invalid because DS2 scores has SotFS scores mixed in, which would generally lower the average scores by critics amd users because it's a rerelease.
Henry Ortiz
Every time I see this pic I get so pissed at how much the artist fucked it up. Its so clear that New Londo is above blight town and Lost Izalith. You literally take an elevator up from Blight Town to get to New Londo
Carter Brown
They are all truly amazing games except for ds2. I will never understand ds2 schizos. Its just indefensibly bad.
Gavin Richardson
Don't try to place BB in a line with it
Jonathan Richardson
>Dark Souls 3 and Elden Ring are most widely popular Soulslike games, with a combination of high sales, decent reviews and high completion rates.
Elden Kino Dark Souls/Dark Souls 3 Sekiro/Bloodborne Pile of garbage More piles of garbage Even more garbage Dark Souls 2
Kayden Davis
>S Sekiro, Bloodborne
>A Dark Souls, Dark Souls 3
>B Elden Ring, Demons Souls
>C Dark Souls 2
Sebastian Howard
I didn't have a ps4 but i lived in multiple different flats with different people that had a ps4 with no bloodborne, so basically i sold the game then bought it again in every town i was living in at the time. Now i have my own ps4 someone gave me theirs for free, bought the game one last time, life is good.
