[CLOUD]: >I saw you laying there... I figured it was too late.
[TIFA]: Wait.. What are you implying? That died? That I'm some kind of imposter?
Tifa is not the real Tifa, she's another girl who saw the real Tifa die and assumed her identity. Cloud is perfectly aware of who he is and that he's not Zach.
The worst part isn't that this is completely plausible, it's that I can picture Nomura doing this to damage control the reason why she "looks different" but forgetting that he completely changed Barret's design too.
Ethan Lewis
>wide spread nude mods now that it's coming to steam thank fucking GOD I haven't drained my balls to tifa since I was like 12, this'll be an absolute blast from the past
Nolan Walker
It's clearly lines taken from two different conversations. The first is from Cloud's memory of the Nibelheim incident, when he comes across wounded Tifa. The second is from the Nibelheim Manor's cellar where files on Cloud, Zack, and Tifa were kept that labelled Cloud and Tifa as 'failures', even though Tifa survived and Cloud's Jenova treatment was actually a success, though Cloud's files will likely have been taken or destroyed by Sephiroth leaving a suspicious gap.