Attached: 339097A2-3742-4FC6-9EF0-24EC2040C2CD.jpg (1400x700, 192.43K)
Which one?
James Perry
Eli Brooks
They're both perfect if you ignore side content (optional mines/caves/catacombs and chalice dungeons)
Hunter Gray
Playing ER only only made me appreciate BB more for its tight and concise structure, lack of repeating bosses, incredible level design, and stable difficulty. There are things I liked about ER more, like the equipment, and weapon arts and shit... but the package in BB is so much better.
Wyatt Thomas
Bloodborne isn't even a passable game, let alone Souls game.
Alexander Sanchez
This. It needed more ER Troon and shit eating shit to be considered a real game by Any Forums
Owen Carter
Chalice dungeons are a thousand times better than whatever the fuck side content elden ring has
Isaac Perez
Bloodborne is Miyazaki's magnum opus
Henry Stewart
I like them about equally for different reasons, which is a huge endorsement for Elden ring because I wasn’t sure FROM could ever top bloodborne for me. I just desperately want it on pc already.
Isaiah Gutierrez
This. It's a masterpiece and comparing it to the dogshit that is Souls games is entirely a disservice to Bloodborne
Anthony Bailey
Elden Ring is an amazing game, and easily one of the best soulsborne games, but there’s a lot of Dark Souls 2 bullshit in it (repeating bosses, adding the same boss but two of them, etc.). Bloodborne is almost perfect
Adam Sanchez
Quality over quantity. Always.
Therefore, I choose Bloodborne.
Leo Rivera
Elden Ring. I'm unironically filtered by PS4 hardware.
Jason Russell
Bloodborne no question
Luis Hughes
Bloodborne has more of a cohesive aesthetic while also being a better game. It's a tighter, more polished, more refined, and overall superior gaming experience to Elden Ring.
Brayden Watson
>Central Yharnam - Gascoigne - Cleric Beast
Fantastic
>Cathedral Ward - Amelia
Fantastic
>Old Yharnam - Blood Starved Beast
Great
>Forbidden Woods - Shadows of Yharnam
Good
>Byrgenwerth - Rom
Disastrous
>Yahar'gul - The One Reborn - Darkbeast Paarl
Paarl is the one saving grace for an area that is among the souls franchise's very worst
>Lecture Building
Eh, should have been attached to the main game world. Otherwise innofensive.
>Nightmare Frontier - Amygdala
Dull, pointless, with a pushover boss
>Nightmare of Mensis - Micolash - Mergo's Wet Nurse
Thoroughly mediocre and often extremely tedious
>Hemwick Charnel Lane - Witches of Hemwick
Refreshing level design, but an utterly worthless boss
>Castle Cainhurst - Martyr Logarius
Classic aesthetic, but painfully underutilised and full of tedious enemies. The run back to Logarius is arduous as well.
>Upper Cathedral Ward
Completely and utterly wasted potential. Shit essentially. Ebrietas is great, but so disconnected from the area it's almost not worth mentioning.
>Hunter's Dream
Only here for the sake of the bosses, but they're both pretty good. One mechanics-wise, and the other thematically/visually.
>Chalices
Garbage
E3, Sekiro, and DS3 are better.
Aaron Evans
For me its still Bloodborne for the gameplay and OST.
Isaiah Myers
Elden Ring shouldn't even be in the same conversation as Bloodborne. BB is far better.
Liam Howard
ER is good but BB is easily much better
Xavier Hernandez
ER and Sekiro are rehashed dogshit where you repeat the same bosses over and over. Not even worth playing
Liam Hill
>DS3 better than BB
opinion safely discarded
Leo Brown
No, chalice dungeons suck, even the preset ones up to the pthumeru queen
Bentley Hill
Bloodborne is the only worthwile game there is
Zachary Brown
both
Oliver Bell
BB makes other soulsgames feel like shit to play
Dylan Taylor
Bloodborne
Andrew Miller
bloodborne easily
Aaron Carter
Even Miyazaki thinks bloodborne is his best work yet.
Evan Jones
Sekiro
Tyler Perry
Both have awful enemy and combat design but BB at least has good level design instead of being another open world slog.
Ryan Rivera
Bloodborne for sure
Josiah Kelly
BB
bonus points for how much it makes pc mastercucks seeth
never ever
Jace Thomas
I liked bloodborne more as a game, but 30 fps kills it so elden ring gets my vote.
Brayden Ortiz
twin peaks of the souls series. Bloodborne has peak aesthetic/story/linear design, Elden Ring has peak gameplay/content/QoL
Xavier King
bloodborne and it's not close.
>t. 220+ hours in elden ring
Gabriel Myers
>Elden Ring has peak gameplay/content/QoL
Landon Nelson
Bloodborne
Parker Butler
sold my ps4, but i would really like to play bloodborne again.