Which is the most overrated?
The consensus top 5 VN’s of all time
Easton King
Ryan Taylor
for comparison my favorite VNs are Higurashi and Steins Gate
999 is the most disappointing thing I have ever read in general, not even pertaining only to VNs
Oliver Taylor
>trannyneko
LOL
John White
I don't know what Bangumi is but them. Clannad is a weird choice, I liked it but I wouldn't rank it that high. Also Kyou is best girl
Levi Nelson
>t. no love
Jayden James
Bangumi looks fine.
Matthew Jenkins
Bagumi is Chinks
Oliver Cox
Maybe Fata Morgana? I havent read it but I just remember it being popular for about a week and then disappearing from the face of the Earth
Angel Powell
Danganronpa probably
Austin Phillips
Also I haven't played Muv Luv but they're fans are pretty bad so I will add that too
Chase Wilson
*their or *its I should say
Jaxon Sanchez
I realize now I misread your post, definitely Reddit is the most overrated
Ah thanks
Cooper Garcia
>Have top 3 favorite VNs same as Reddit
Maybe I am a Redditor.
Benjamin Scott
>Top Tier
Fate/Stay Night
Tsukihime
Every Gyakuten Saiban game ever made besides that Layton spinoff garbage
999
Danganronpa 2
Any Rance game
School Days
>Mid Tier
Muv Luv Alternative
YU-NO
Steins Gate
Chaos Head
Ever17
Umineko - (Question Arcs)
Snatcher
Danganronpa 1
Higurashi (question arc)
>Low Tier
Subahibi
Chaos Child
Danganronpa V3
Muramasa
Higurashi Kai (Answer Arcs)
Steins Gate 0
Virtues Last Reward
>Bottom Tier
Zero Time Dilemma
Grisaia
Majikoi
Umineko Chiru (Answer Arcs)
Fata Morgana
Clannad
White Album
Andrew Howard
Not in list but Monster Girl Quest. It's a fun game but it's often Any Forumss first VN. So the fans and posters talk it up more than it really is as the world's greatest bait and switch porn game.
Daniel White
>Most Overrated
Absolutely Umineko.
It was fun for three and a half episodes and then got really fucking boring. Dropped it like a few hours into episode 6.
Erogamscape is the least bad, followed closely by VNDB just because Muramasa is genuinely funny as all hell and the girls are hot as fuck and the chuuni is FRESH.
Jayden Ward
Those are most people's first or second experience with long VNs, which is why they rank high on every list
Jack Hernandez
I mean honestly, the top 10s of all those places are all the same games but in different orders. Arguing about which of the best belong in which order sounds kind of silly to me because it's a matter of taste.
I like urban fantasy so Steins;Gate, Dengeki Styker, and Little Busters are my three favorites. Probably not a shock to reveal that my other top picks are shit like Demonbane, Tsukihime, Fate, Rewrite, and Uta trilogy (though that last one is certainly not urban fantasy whatsoever)
Jonathan Lewis
>Low Tier
>Subahibi
>Chaos Child
>Steins Gate 0
hard disagree on Dang It Ron 3 and putting S;G in mid while sucking off School Days and 999 muh sudoku lol , but at least you seem to have a good head on your shoulders and can call garbage garbage.
Aiden Mitchell
>Fate/Gay Night in top spot
The rest of the list promptly ignored
Dylan Nelson
it's good and very 'fresh' in terms of art and topic for a VN, but yes, it is super overrated like Muramasa. Overrated does NOT mean bad, just, overrated.