Who did open world better?

Who did open world better?

Attached: elden ring vs zelda.jpg (1400x700, 197.46K)

Other urls found in this thread:

ign.com/articles/the-10-best-open-world-games
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

BOTW and it not even close

Left: Dark fantasy for mature adults wanting an epic adventure

Right: 30th rehash of Miyamoto's senile remembrance of wandering the hills of Japan as a child. Actual game for children, some reason played by overweight NEETs wearing Nintendo graphic tees.

Attached: 1646934309788.png (778x950, 624.52K)

Elden Ring mogged BOTW so hard that Nintendo pushed back the dlc to 2023. Guess shoving shitty shrines, ugly goblins and korok's seeds in people's faces wasn't going to cut it.
The giga classic dungeons alone are superior to the entirety of BOTW anyway.

Elden Ring because It actually has dungeons.

>BOTW and it not even close

Attached: 1647196727903.jpg (800x1024, 72.46K)

FPBP

ign.com/articles/the-10-best-open-world-games

botw completely demolishes elden ring's world but good luck making fromdrones deviate from their script and admit it

Elden Ring solely due to having actual underground areas

Attached: workout.png (648x321, 259.5K)

BotW
>launched to overwhelming critical acclaim.
>rival game developers also applaud and shower praise on it, heralding the game as a new high benchmark in game design, opting to copy BotW's design into their own games and even holding seminars teaching BotW to up-coming game developers

Elden Ring
>launched to overwhelming critical acclaim
>rival developers pour scorn and suspicion over review scores as they generally don't consider the game to be that good.

Chucklesome I must admit.

>dark fantasy for mature adults
>game for children

Attached: incel edge.gif (498x466, 581.74K)

is that a... a... A HECKIN KOROK'S SEED??? And a BOKOBLIN'S CAMP??? And behind it... behind it... isn't it another EPIC SHRINE? HOLY FUCKING SHIT BASED NINTENDO THIS IS THE EPITOME OF GAMING WOOOOOOOW!!!!

Attached: 1647143051978.jpg (640x427, 56.28K)

>97

KEK

hi snoy

They were both entertaining for about an hour before it got repetitive and tedious
Elden Ring at least has actual places to explore though

BOTW.
Elden Rings is so static it feels like a glorified skybox.

Your bitching won't change a thing about BOTW being a boring streamer bait turd.

You have to acknowledge that Botw had far, far more technical limitations. It came out many years ago, on far weaker systems. So graphics comparisons are entirely unfair.

Attached: botw secrets.png (3264x626, 2.4M)

Genshin impact

It's all shit.

Elden Ring was great, but BoTW's climbing, paragliding, mounts, and overall movement made it a better world. That and the fact that there are actually villages.

I played 150 hours in BotW and have still gone back to it over the years because its so much fun to play.

Dropped Elden Ring after about 20 hours. If I didn't have a digital copy I would have probably tried to get a refund.

Tendies are seething and relentlessly coming up with the most retarded nitpicks and contrarian-tard critics.

Is that a... A HECKIN RUIN FRAGMENT??? And a GUY IN KNIGHT ARMOR??? And behind it... behind it... isn't it another CHEST WITH A GOLDEN RUNE IN IT? HOLY FUCKING SHIT BASED FROMSOFT THIS IS THE EPITOME OF GAMING WOOOOOOOW!!!!

botw has an immense amount of soul compared to every other open world title and it's the worst zelda game

they both had their positives and negatives and trying to paint it as a flat "X is better!!!" is reductive and retarded

there actually are many villages and settlements in elden ring. it's just that they are inhabited by zombies, cultists and madmen, in typical fromsoft fashion

Who considers Elden Ring open world? It's very linear.