These are "fixed" edits of Quaxly posted here when the Gen 9 starters were first revealed.
These are "fixed" edits of Quaxly posted here when the Gen 9 starters were first revealed
Luis Barnes
Brandon Myers
Obviously middle is the official design
Hudson Kelly
bottom and top left aren't bad
Michael Cruz
My edit :)
Dylan Richardson
Is he based off Donald duck or something.
Caleb Stewart
the design is too boring and creatively bankrupt to be fixed desu
Cameron Smith
All the fixes are just a duck, the water wings one is the only one even mildly more interesting.
Tyler Carter
All of them look worse somehow
Nathan Sanchez
On god just about every "fix" I've seen on this fucking board has been miles shittier than the original design. Even if its a pokemon with an objective shit design.
Parker Cox
>all of them remove the entire point of its design which not only gives it an interesting sailor theme which makes it stand out but is also based on an actual thing on real life ducks
like usual fans are retards and horrible at redesigning pokemon.
Chase Wood
some of them kinda look like digimon
Julian Cruz
u w8 m8
Andrew Moore
they really gave fangs to a duck lmao
Carter Carter
The original is so stupid it's based. I'm picking it for sure.
Brody Nelson
Just you wait, final evo is going to have a big anime pompadour and everyone will love it.
Cooper Evans
How come Murkrow can have a hat but the duck can’t
Nolan Hill
Old good new bad mentality
Michael Nguyen
god I hate how that stupid duck looks.
Andrew Ramirez
If / p/ was in charge of designing Pokémon, everything would be generic elemental animals
Logan Sanchez
>NOOOOO YOU CAN'T BE JUST A COOL DUCK MONSTER YOU HAVE TO HAVE SOME SHIT ANTHRO GIMMICK OR IT'S NOT "CREATIVE" ENOUGH!
Hunter Ortiz
I can see what they were trying to do, they are trying to get rid of the bad parts of the design:
>Overly large cutesy head
>Shitty non-Pokemon eyes
>Gay hand pose
>Human being hat
>Non threatening mouth
I don't think they did a great job, but heart in the right place.
Jaxon Garcia
top left one is best
Mason Foster
If fans were in charge of designing Pokémon, everything would be furbait jobmo- oh wait.
Adam Evans
Correct.
Hunter Barnes
>Implying that was always the design strategy and that it's a good one
Make Pokemon cool again.
Brayden Garcia
god those edits are ugly as shit
Jonathan Gutierrez
>>Implying that was always the design strategy
Correct.
Carson Turner
>Real Pokemon Eyes
>Actually looks like something wild and not a mascot
>No human design elements anywhere besides "has facial expression"
Even your specific example is nowhere close to the toyetic gimmick mons of later gens.
Isaiah Kelly
>crested ducks don't live in the wild
go outside
Carter Long
>Crested ducks have baby heads and hats and do the gay pose
Stay inside
Owen Young
>palm trees don't have human faces and do the gay pose
damn
Angel Hughes
>Making something into a monster is the same as making something into a mascot/human
Nope, good try though.