This should have ended the streak

A cash-in ends streak bullshit without taking anything away from Taker.
23 was the perfect year to pull what Seth did and no one was expecting someone to win and cash in the same night yet.

>gaytch ending the streak
AHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAH

breaking the streak while half assing it with a cheap win, thats fucking retarded.

Triple H is so cool

the real redpill is no one should have ended it after WM 24
It was not going to elevate anyone at that point
The only thing it did was leave a bad taste in everyone's mouth and sour people off WWE

agreed, the young upstart Triple H needed the momentum going into his next feud against *checks notes* Paul Heyman

Pretty much, Orton in 21 would've made the most sense but he didn't want to

It could have been cheap at that point because it only became a thing worth mentioning two years prior when Orton took it, and the year after that he fought Henry in a nothing match and feud.
23 and 24 we're hot enough to be big deals and still have someone take it be it Edge cheating or Punk cashing in, which would also push up the MITB.

Instead we are in the Brock took it timeline and we see he absolutely should not have. Especially if the rub of beating post streak Brock was just going to go to a 90 year old Goldberg.

just because brock breaking it wasnt ideal doesnt mean you should half ass it and give it to punk of all people, batista breaking it at 23 wouldve been interesting, cena if they ever wanted to do a heel run as well.

Orton at 23, he win the MITB and the same night cashing in against Taker after he just won the big gold against Batista finally ending the legend killer era. Simple as.

Brock was the right choice

Brock breaking the streak was fine, the problem is they wasted the Brock rub on FUCKING GOLDBERG.

How is cashing in half-assed?
Taker beats Batista in the match they had, barely makes it up and then is attacked by the MITB winner.

Works just as well

Fact is after 25, no one should've broke it.
Before that, there are only 3 who could have done this and have gotten good heat for it.

FPBP
Either him or Orton.

its half assed because the guy didnt actually beat taker yet its still breaking his streak, after building it up for years thats a retarded way of giving the rub to someone. its like if say roman keeps his belt til next mania then loses to the olympics nog via distraction roll up.

The end of the streak should have been taker's last match, instead he wrestles 5 more matches and loses another one