>Tell my dad God hates communists
>I argue that redistribution of wealth is merely popular extortion justified through popular consent, and God said Thou shalt not covet.
>He argues back that it is within people's right to ask for shares of products they took part in making
>He also argued that people should seek communal happiness, and redistribution of wealth is the key
>I argue back that it is communist logic because it tempers with demand and supply, which decides the value of said participants, and wealth does not equate material wealth, meaning distributing money does not necessarily bring prosperity to the entire community
>He still tells me it is an ideal people should strive for, despite our human nature preventing us from achieving it
>I partially agree that primitive communism is indeed idealistic, but it is out of the question in our current world.
>Mom barges in and kick out both of us, the argument ends.
What should be done about my dad?
Help my dad is a communist catholic
Christ was the first communist
Redirect him to the passages in the catechism that outright reject communism and defend property rights.
Amen brother
/thread
Holy fuck are you autistic. Your dad is right and you're a faggot. Stop fucking with the only people in your life that care about you for the amusement of anonymous strangers.
>right
Why
First question, are you white?
if you are white, then kill him to preserve honor of white race
If you aren't then kill yourself
>my dad murdered me in a debate, what should be done about him?
if you can’t defeat his arguments, either he’s right or you’re unequipped for intelligent discussion of the subject, either from lack of intelligence or knowledge
Commie
>communist
>christian
Tell him to pick one.
Their share in the product is the wages that they agreed to make it for. Anything more than that is coveting the belongings of others, which is a mortal sin
>this
Inside the family that can be done,sth alike socialism. And still,there is private property. They key is that family is natural,comes from natural laws. And still,the ascription to a family is volunteer,once you are old you choose,even its advisable and good yo hace s good RS with your family.
So in any other way,so as society, that wont work. Its never volunteer
You shall no steal
you have obviously been completely brainwashed by kikes. b-but muh profit motive! m-muh supply and demand! yes, what about it? those aren't goal of humanity or objectively good moral things. even you seem to faintly understand what an ideal society would be like, you just refuse to work towards it becaise you feel like you're being 'extorted' by contributing to others (aka greed) . the double standard and inconsistency of you using Gods "do not covet" as an argument for your position in the very same breath makes you look like a complete child and a drooling retard.
Tell him to go to North Korea and see if he's allowed to practice his faith.
Nope. His dad is a misinformed, envious and spiteful person
You're essentially wrong within the framework of Christianity, and especially Catholicism. You can make an argument for why people shouldn't be FORCED to part with their possessions, but you can't make an argument for why you should be reluctant to part with your possessions in the first place. Sure it's wrong to steal from people, but if you're of the faith, why are you resisting? Jesus, talking to his own disciples, told them to leave all their shit behind to follow him. He makes it very clear over the course of the Gospels that even if you can make it into heaven with a lot of money in your estate, the money didn't help you, it only made your bad situation worse. Jesus instructs that it's easier to earn your eternal reward if you ditch the material attachments, give your shit to the poor, dedicate your life to service and accept death when it comes. Why fight these outcomes when they lead inexorably to eternal life (allegedly)? Nothing on this Earth is superior in value to an eternal life of bliss, if indeed that eternal and blissful life is actually available.
There are answers to all of your dad's stupid ideas, but you won't find them in Christianity.
> muh Jewsus
The argument is about the insane amount of crimes behind those fortunes, ongoing crimes by those people and how it's impossible to put those sociopaths on trial because it would take millions of years. (((Marx))) and other jews obfuscated the situation on purpose.
If there are any critical businesses that aren't involved in crime (so a more violent "RICO" takeover doesn't make sense) but still need temporary control, they can be bought by the state just like Japan did.
>a bunch of reddit text
>some anime shit saved on pc
who the fuck cares whatever you said was probably dumb anyway kys if you type up that much
He’s not a communist. Communism in its essence relies on the absence of God and the belief that all people are one - despite obvious differences. Your father is a proper Christian in this regard and globalist Jews need to covet less. Lil less Talmud and lil more Torah.
Our vision of God is subjective but the real GOYIM are the ones who do not subscribe to the Ten Commandments.
I don't get the point of this post. It's so obviously weak as a response, I can't imagine what you're hoping to get as a reply.