Why is Chinese Propaganda so bad?

Let's not turn this into a pro/anti China thread or pro/anti USA thread. This question specifically is about the quality of their propaganda:

youtu.be/hI5VmdKOAUA
youtube.com/watch?v=6og10hBza04
youtu.be/WIRe-3mghpQ
youtu.be/ususUbhZr1M
youtube.com/shorts/r4t9tu9tbIM

I feel like this kind of stuff works on the domestic populace but it just doesn't work well for foreigners. Also, why does the first one have talking animals and sea shanties like a kid's cartoon? And why is the biggest redpill dropped "foreign intervention bad. I feel like I could do a way better job as a Chinese propaganda producer. This shit is just horrible.

Attached: Cropped-1631941008photo_SXM2021091000004312.jpg (3500x1968, 1.11M)

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=IWP56VIgPIw
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1989_Tiananmen_Square_protests_and_massacre
twitter.com/NSFWRedditVideo

Just like their products, they are poorly made

But it's like they don't understand the propaganda used for their domestic people doesn't work for foreigners. Even when they have some white person reading a script you can tell some chinese dude plugged it into google translate and had him read it. They need to get legitimate english speaking script writers because when you can see some white guy going "China is a very strong country, contrary to western belief. In China I see many great things that I did not see in the west. In the west life was bad and I worked very hard. In China my life is good and the people rally around the party in unity." it is obviously not the way we talk and it kills the legitimacy of the propaganda from the start.

Bugs lack creativity, they think calling us racist will offend us, but in reality it just ends up hilarious, pic related is an example that just ends up being funny.

Attached: zn9je12nsyl51.png (1200x720, 1.1M)

Nothing the CCP produces makes any sense outside China. They're extremely adept at dealing with their own people and the Chinese mentality, but these tactics come off as forced and weird to anyone in the Anglosphere.

The most effective Chinese propaganda is not overtly political. The most effective Chinese prop is just video montages of their downtowns or some pretty temples and smiling villagers. Everybody in America has a negative view of society now so if you can depict China as a place on the rise and everybody is happy and their cities are dazzling and their temples are beautiful and even little village people are enjoying life then that is what will brainwash people in the west to at least be neutral towards them.

But when China comes out swimming with the "We are powerful our system is number 1!" it alienates people in the west.

Kek

Attached: mutt world.webm (568x320, 2.86M)

That's not Chinese produced that's Any Forums produced of course it's going to be 100000x more effective than Chinese prop.

Propaganda...... For any reason need to do. Maybe for ur politician vote.

You will never able to pull this off in your country, it would be full off niggers.

Attached: 1657127574640.webm (856x482, 1.46M)

But this isn't really effective propaganda in the West. This is great for Chinese people. Overt displays of militarism are ways to foster domestic pride but to the outside world it comes off as a insecurity and having to prove yourself to the world. DPRK puts on better military parades yet China is clearly a better power than DPRK. Once again, their domestic propaganda is great for Chinese people but nothing translates to be effective for the West. The best propaganda they have for Westerners are the travel vlogs where they get some supposed native Uyghur girl to vlog Xinjiang and say how great it is without going into politics.

To the enemies of China and those who oppress peoples, to you, the West:

Your time will come. And that day is ever approaching. You have oppressed your own people and destroyed the natural order of being that goes against man. You have attacked all of humanity through your cultural warfare on your own people and supposed allies solely to maintain false dictum. That must be stopped. We can't see evil perpetuated at such a scale in which you wage it and stand idly by, for that would mean complicity. You have destroyed and corrupted far too many generations and cultures. You stand against all that is humanity, all that are the people. Evil, that's what defines you. For centuries you have abused mankind's achievements by weaponizing them against developing countries and defenseless peoples. You use our Chinese inventions not for the betterment of man, but to satiate your lust of gratuitous violence, especially on the weaker. We have come to understand that your imperialism in not solely based on occupation, but your exportation and imposition of your perverted culture. You have entrenched these people in your culturally occupied territories as puppet governments, especially through he support of kleptocratic regimes. These people must be removed. Let it be known, let the world know, the forces of light, the iron will of the Chinese people, and our tenacious resolve will make sure you are sent back into the depths of darkness from which you came and where you belong. Forever righteous, forever for the people. Glory to the party, glory to the people, glory to the homeland.

youtube.com/watch?v=IWP56VIgPIw

Attached: 000000000.jpg (2400x1350, 805.23K)

chinks are dumb

China has had a problem with quality control for a long time!

Attached: ChineseTapeMeasures.webm (360x640, 1.36M)

Wolf warrior propaganda DOES NOT translate outside of China. I'm trying to help you. Save that shit for domestic use. Why would it appeal to foreigners when you go "FUCK YOU WE'RE THE FUTURE AND IF YOU ATTACK CHINA YOU ARE RACIST COLONIZER!" Just show some videos of Chongqing and some temples and pretty ladies lighting a lantern.

they killed the creative ones more than once throughout their history

yeah yeah chink faggot stop talking and do something bitch nigger, ill send you pelosi i double dog dare you to make a move. come on faggot.

>effective propaganda in the West.
You are too brainwashed by CNN. China don't need you. For China, USA is not different to Africa. Food supply in both.
But USA need China for eveything. American propaganda had a reverse effect on China.
In fact, each time, you post a western thread like this, you loose. Keep continuing and USA will be overtaken by Africa.

hello Chinese poster lets talk about the Tiananmen Square protests and massacre

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1989_Tiananmen_Square_protests_and_massacre

Tibet and Taiwan are good as a free and independent nation ....thanks for the opinion user

it's the same problem that prevents china from becoming a global influence like america is, they are insulated, most of their population have no experience of western culture and no interaction with it, they mainly copy stuff on the surface level like the wolf warrior stuff and other rara america shit from 80s and then make chinese versions of it thinking that those will influence western countries like american movies have influenced west in the past, there never will be chinese century because of this, they live in a literal bubble and rest of the world doesn't even know about china other than the surface level shit they push here, but they would have to open up which poses a risk of them being subverted instead of them subverting the west, what do?

>Chinaman bad

Attached: 1658942622118.jpg (674x773, 114.75K)

Attached: 1657896306815.jpg (750x962, 253.36K)