How do you look at this beast, and say "yeah, this person won't have a competitive advantage"

How do you look at this beast, and say "yeah, this person won't have a competitive advantage"

Attached: 1636214038869.jpg (2500x1567, 494.67K)

WHO GIVES A SHIT

if you knew anything about women's swimming you would know that katie ledecky's times absolutely crushed this giga hon and that the current year's competition was a lot worse than previous years

but rightoids can't handle reality

you have to be blinded by ideology. if you press them hard enough they'll say "some people are just bigger than others, deal with it" ignoring that MTF trans people are bigger because they went through male puberty which cis women can't experience

Attached: Thomas-1024x677.jpg (1024x677, 64.41K)

Katie Ledecky is an outlier in terms of performance

>tfw Michael fucking Phelps legitimately thinks Katie Ledecky could go toe-to-toe with him but has not once been concerned with this collegiate-level girl's decent performances
Come back to me when Lia actually competes in the Olympics, until then it's back to pol with you

agreed, so should katie be banned from competitive swimming because she is objectively so much better than every other female swimmer that it's not even close to being fair?

only by 9 seconds

So why shouldn't she be competing with people who can actually compete against her? Isn't her advantage unfair too?

>only by 9 seconds
that is a long fucking time, user

Pro swimmers are concerned with every hundredth of a second they can shave off. 9 seconds is the difference between 1st and 30th at best

>those shoulders

>How do you look at this beast, and say "yeah, this person won't have a competitive advantage"

Attached: honswimmer.png (1080x727, 472.41K)

>we can always tell
>those shoulders are obviously male
Retardbrained

Attached: BWCM_Katie_Web-cutout-e1565099568300.png (450x1222, 219.64K)

i do think she doesn’t fit the guides for fair competition. but this isn’t an excuse to discriminate against all trans women. even among males and females as a whole, there is quite a lot of crossover in physiological proportions. that isn’t even considering the fact that trans women go through a second puberty. if we want sports to be fair, we create guidelines and those who fit inside should be eligible to compete. we can’t discriminate against a 16 year old girl who got on blockers at 12 just because a 22 year old on hormones for 12 months wins a competition. that is equally unfair, if not more unfair, than what cis competitors are facing

because I'm not dumb enough to confuse a gut feeling with actual data and since all the actual data I've seen says she's just another mid college swimmer so that's what I believe

>doesn’t fit the guides for fair competition
ban katie ledecky
ban katie ledecky
ban katie ledecky

The IOC already bans cisgender women whose advantage is caused by T levels which abnormally high. Trans women are different, though: those have experienced male puberty now have an irreversible advantage over cis women even if their current testosterone levels dropped after starting HRT. This, however, didn't make Lia Thomas massive shoulders go away. Competing against her is like competing against a former steroid user whose body has been permanently enhanced by testosterone. You must realize this, because we always talk about how puberty causes irreversible and irreparabile damage to trans women.
Ledecky, on the other hand, has acceptable T levels and never went through male puberty.

Attached: IMG_20220702_055840.jpg (720x1783, 446.89K)

Finally, a good fucking take
The most fair and ethical method is a biometric scale which considers height, weight, bone density, muscle mass, and other more particular factors for each sport. If cis women really cared about their own prestige they'd let their most powerful women compete against men to show that its possible for women to beat men in competition.

Bro, like, who even cares
You care about sports? Fuckin normie