Why does every fucking site insist on putting this shit out of order...

This one?

Attached: shitthread.jpg (711x553, 100.7K)

Thanks

>many think that this is the way Haruhi is supposed to be watched
Yeah, including the authors? How is this even debated?
>S2 was broadcast in chronological order in 2009 so it shouldn't really appear in the left column. Was this made by a redditor or something?

oh shit, is that OnlyAfro?

No sane person is ever going to watch Haruhi for their first time first in 2006 broadcast order then again in 2009 broadcast with the repeat episodes, no matter how much you post this.
The left column simply shows the remaining episodes left to watch after having watched season 1.

>I want to turn it into an "I did that!" sticker
how and where would you even use them?

Attached: 1648662332571.jpg (269x480, 25.63K)

>sane
Do sane people need to binge the entire franchise in one week?
Just watch S1 first then take a break and watch something else for a few months. It has so much care for detail and rewatch potential that I'd argue for watching S1 twice before watching the rest.

Most people don’t rewatch a show after just a few months.
And definitely not if there is more of that show they have yet seen. It is simply retarded.

And most shows don't have this kind of bs about ordering and such. Why not take some informed advice from fans on how to best enjoy it?
>Most people don’t rewatch a show after just a few months.
Does it really count as rewatch if the episodes are completely reordered? The experience is different: you get to connect the dots and understand how things went down.
>inb4 you should already understand the story perfectly
I'm imagining the average lazy speedwatcher that will miss most of the details, you're not one of them right user?

Could this be considered one the greatest pieces of anime there is?

Most fans are either saying, just watch it chronologically or to watch it in 2006 broadcast and then watch the S2 episodes after. That’s the informed advice from fans.
>Does it really count as rewatch if the episodes are completely reordered?
Of course it does, because you’ve already watched it. Just because I restructure the episodes doesn’t mean I suddenly forgot everything about the episodes.
>you should already understand the story perfectly
What story? Haruhi doesn’t have a connective story except for preventing Haruhi from destroying the world. All you really do is get a better understanding of the chronology which really isn’t that important, hence the scrambled order in the first place.

Melancholy VI is a good way to end the first season, and makes sense since the first book was written to potentially be a standalone. That's why the series stagnates development wise so quickly afterwards.
Someday in the Rain -> Disappearance is something really special though.

I like to rewatch in chronological, mostly, but I think either is fine for your first run. Endless Eight works well in the middle, I like to watch one episode per day. You're missing out if you skip it, I think it's a really cool choice.

it's the best from the 2000s that's for sure

Attached: 1637098554035.png (3000x5800, 3.28M)

Not from what I've seen of it. It's decent but not even the best from KyoAni. Love Super Driver though.

>Most fans are either saying, just watch it chronologically or to watch it in 2006 broadcast and then watch the S2 episodes after. That’s the informed advice from fans.
[Citation needed]
Is this consensus just based on that copy-pasted image?
I don't want to insist too much on this but I feel like rewatching a 14ep show isn't that much of a burden considering shonenfags endure hundreds of episodes of filler

>Someday in the Rain -> Disappearance is something really special though.
Agreed, and this is how it's intended by the authors