Manga are nothing but glorified storyboards and the idea that some people feel elitist over consuming manga is...

Manga are nothing but glorified storyboards and the idea that some people feel elitist over consuming manga is laughable to me.

Attached: storyboard-by-makoto-shinkai-vol-2-your-name-book-15.jpg (1000x700, 515.91K)

who asked?

I don't think you've ever read a manga if that's what you're comparing it to.

books are nothing but glorified scripts and the idea that some people feel elitist over consuming books is laughable to me.

Storyboards have more dimension to them though, not as simple. And your example is even also another story, Shinkai does all of it all by himself. It's almost impossible finding an anime film that's still made like that.

Isn't anime the same, though? They don't go straight to what you see in the screen.

Attached: 1635627219881.png (1828x1080, 1.62M)

Storyboards are better than most manga.

I find it hard to read manga but not books, I rarely get invested/immersed in reading manga for some reason

stories are nothing but glorified oral tradition and the idea that some people feel elitist over consuming stories is laughable to me.

Attached: Saxo1[1].gif (746x1071, 610.01K)

Anime are just glorified advertisements for the source material

hasn't been true for a long time

Manga are storyboards with more possibilities of rearrangement, structure, frame sizing and shape, spacing, divisions, and composition. Manga are key frames with less wasted effort on imbetweens that save a lot of effort and allow storytellers to focus on what really matters, allowing for better told stories. Manga are not able to be ruined by a single person except the original mangaka, so if the mangaka is competent, it's not like an anime where just because a main VA, sound director, chief director, animation director, key animators, 3D staff, script writer/adaptor fucks up the entire anime can become a laughingstock.

Attached: a68.jpg (350x474, 35.14K)

Are you good? It's more true than ever zoomzoom

Do you only read 4komas? Because that's not how paneling or text balloons work

it has been especially true in recent years
most shows are just low effort 1 cour ads now

>single person
>artist+writer combos don't exists
>assistants don't exits
>editors don't exits
>publishers don't exists

>Manga are storyboards with more possibilities of rearrangement, structure, frame sizing and shape, spacing, divisions, and composition
Yeah that's the glorified part. At the end of the day it's still a lame stpryboard that doesn't feel alive in the slightest.

>Manga are nothing but glorified storyboards
Try animating something yourself and see if you agree later.

not really, series usually get multiple seasons now if they do well which was a lot less likely in the past.

the thing about manga isn't that they are ineherently better, but by definition they have infinite freedom of expression an lack of limits compared to animation

this is Your Name right

>that doesn't feel alive in the slightest.
you just aren't used (yet) to fill the "void" with your own head, not as an insult, but it's the only way I can think could make you say something like that

You didn't disprove the overall argument
To 5s maybe

Attached: WKCZ1OacnpzGjKDo__42-xSdcSoJUFsymakNJG1vEP8.jpg (640x339, 18.48K)

The argument is stupid because you are trying to argue against the merits of collaborative art. Ever heaard of Cinema? Bands? Symphonies?

You don't know anything about the manga industry or anime industry, do you?

>Treating story boards like they're the finished piece v.s. being production notes for directing & animation.
You might as well say you prefer reading a script v.s. a finished movie.

what a retarded thread
🤢🤢🤢
kys OP