Unironically and without memeing, what exactly did she do wrong? She even confirms that she only stole the remanents of Madoka's human side and that the power of the Law of Cycles is still functioning. Now everyone in the cast gets to be happy and live the normal lives they deserve. Seems like Sayaka was just acting like an asshole for no reason in the end.
Unironically and without memeing, what exactly did she do wrong...
Christian Perry
Ethan Long
Nothing. Only actual brainlets thinks he did something wrong and they don't even know why they think this. The best they can come up with is "B-BUT MADOKA DIDN'T CONSENT"
Bentley Miller
Nothing, you can call her selfish but base Madoka admitted she'd like to keep being with her family.
LITERALLY no one suffers from what she did, except QB, but fuck QB.
Aaron Brooks
She did nothing wrong. The incubators are the villains and Madoka chose to do what she did only because of what they started in the first place. But Urobuchi is probably convinced and dead set in making her a villain, i can't wait to see what sort of hacks he will come up with to make this happen.
Jacob Cox
She did the right thing with the Kyuubei "incident" but the things she did to Madoka was a bit questionable. She could arguably apotheosize in a different way, but personally I'm on her side, because supposedly the LoC and other meguca would lose their individuality more and more until they cease into nothingness.
Ethan Bell
>what exactly did she do wrong?
My last Rebellion rewatch was in 2020, so my brain might be a little cloudy, but.
It's obvious she's fucking insane and has very little self-esteem to call herself the devil.
Kaiten will show it. Urobuchi is guaranteed to pull a weirdass plot like with Rebellion, but the meat of the story is that just as Homu foretold in the epilogue to Madoka
>Well, then, I suppose, one day, you will also be my enemy. It's fine. I don't care.
Something is fucked up. Maybe the law of cycles will attempt to purify Homura, but supposing she really does have power over said law, what Homura means is that Madoka's new fate is very rapey and not very enjoyable because Homu has no restraints anymore and can live the dream with her love toy.
Nothing wrong.
Brody Richardson
Not raping Madoka.
Luis Morgan
Why are you so sure she didn't?
Gavin Bailey
ethically speaking she still kidnapped madoka, and is holding her against her will (if someone tries to leave every time their memory starts to come back, and you keep wiping their memory, that's not them consenting to stay)
strategically speaking she left Sayaka, Kyoko etc to inevitably regain partial memories and their powers, and become magical girls trying to defeat the evil devil homura (how they'll see it) and keep trying to topple her, which will make it more likely for her grip on Madoka's memories to slip up.
put simply her current position is too poorly defended, in that there's not enough obstacles between Madoka meguca valkyries and Madoka herself. Even if she produces monsters to keep them occupied in typical meguca villainess fashion, she'd need more obfuscation to hide behind
Isaac Campbell
"I wasn't even supposed to BE HERE today!"
Isaac Reyes
She went against Madoka's wish and is holding her against her will.
Adrian Foster
Madoka is 14 and Homura is 20+. She knows what's best for her.
Andrew Reed
Madoka's wish is unimpaired, and she approved of Homura's actions.
Jaxson Gutierrez
>Madoka's wish is unimpaired
She explicitly asked to do it herself.
>she approved of Homura's actions
We have no idea.
Dominic Jackson
The only thing she did wrong was thinking she didn't deserve the same hapiness she gave to all the other girls
Angel Reyes
Madoka is as old as humanity
Robert Sullivan
>She explicitly asked to do it herself.
So? Having a human existence doesn't interfere with that at all. We saw that in episode 12, when she stood human in Mitakihara with Homura and Kyubey while ‘simultaneously’ visiting every magical girl across time and space in person.
Eli James
If Homura is so right, then why is the anime called Madoka and not Homura?
Brandon Butler
>We have no idea.
Yes, we do. “As I am now, I can see everything that ever has or will have happened. All the universes that could have been, and those that may yet come to be. Every single one.” Madoka didn't say ‘o noes plz don't give me my life back’, she told Homura “It's too early to give up.” In the chair scene, Homura was checking that she got it right.
Benjamin Carter
Being a lesbian is morally wrong
Ayden Hall
Not kissing Madoka
Evan Davis
>Unironically and without memeing, what exactly did she do wrong?
appearing in a shit show