While do magical girls always get such rough beatings? It's so brutal

While do magical girls always get such rough beatings? It's so brutal

Attached: yes I know it's a boy shut up .gif (500x280, 3.59M)

Because Madoka ruined the genre.

user, I just know that you've never actually watched it and just blindly hating it. Give it a watch at least, or even a rewatch if you've actually seen it

Pretty sure this stems more from Precure than Madoka.

Precure is slowly phasing out its fights, to the point where they're minimal.
While Nanoha planted some of the seeds, it was Madoka who turned the genre into a ryona subgenre.

how though? I don't recall any beatings in madoka, most there was was when mamis head but eaten "which is more guro" and homura having the building fall on her. nothing like pic

Attached: 23.jpg (1272x1798, 556.62K)

I don't think that's true but at least you aren't one of those people that say Madoka didn't influence anything in the genre, because I don't know what those idiots are smoking.

MGRP's first novel, what this scene is from, was written before Madoka aired.

It rewrote the magical girl design book so every single magical girl show has to be dark, violent and depressing.
The over the top physical violence is just the natural follow-up to this particular template.

This. Madoka didn't actually revolutionize the genre, it just got popular, which meant both attempts to recapture it (eg YuYuYu) and its contemporary influences being adapted and popularized (eg MGRP).

Madoka's influence is in greatly increasing the popularity of the dark mahou shoujo style. It's not the first dark show, but that's disingenuous because nothing is really "first".

>contemporary influences
>MGRP
That came out a year and a half after Madoka aired

Try reading retard

That's what I said. It got popular, so more things got written to be like it. It could have happened with any particular dark magical girl show.

>MGRP's first novel, what this scene is from, was written before Madoka aired.

It doesn't matter if the edgefest you like was written 20 years before Madoka, it was Madoka who make the dark magical girl genre popular and got people interested on it.
Madoka also replaced Sailor Moon as the magical girl template so even if the show isn't serious it still follows Madoka's pointers.

I see. Tasteful suffering turned into suffering porn

Why are madokafags so insufferably retarded?

Is this the ryona thread? I’m confused

Why do you care so much?

Are you denying that Madoka is the new mahou shoujo paradigm?
One of the reasons I hate Madoka is due to that.

Because they pop up everywhere to spout their bullshit

Because cute girls getting brutally beaten = shocking and unconventional.