What went wrong?
What went wrong?
Jaxson Lee
Tyler Gutierrez
elves are not black. end of discussion.
Cameron Phillips
Elves at Helm's Deep is my only major complaint.
It's a bit too much of an action movie like RotK, but there isn't nearly as much dumb shit, so it comes out better.
Brody Wood
3000 vs 10K in book.
300 + 150 eleves vs 10000 orcs in movie.
Still a badass scene though.
Daniel Gomez
Hey ho, merry day a dillo
What's not aright with this here film?
It lacks certain rhyme and festive whim
of gay Old Tom Bombadil-oh!
Brody Bailey
we never get to see inside the towers
Juan Gomez
CGI
William Powell
All.
Peter Jackson sucks.
Kayden Lewis
>What went wrong?
It's fucking boring
Anthony Roberts
Get a RoP(e), shill.
Your show bombed and is only beloved by pajeets.
Mason Smith
Too much ents not enough Frodo and Sam.
I’d say Aragorns Legolas and gimli storyline is the standout of the movie.
Jack Turner
Did you chimp out when the whole first half of the book had no Frodo?
Bentley Ross
What went RIGHT?
John Cruz
It deviated from the books and a lot of important scenes weren't included while adding nonsense. The cast clearly loved Tolkien and together with the music is what saved this trilogy, yet compared to what Hollywood has produced the past 9 decades the quality is discernible, it's just that the bar is too low.
Connor Peterson
Arwen should have been black and part of the fellowship
William Nelson
I don’t read books
Justin Rogers
it shows
Chase Adams
nothing, it's the best of the trilogy.
>b-but muh cgi
Fellowship had cgi that holds up worse, and it wasn't even necessary in a lot of cases, such as the scene with the Watcher. TTT uses cgi sparingly, only for the cases where practical effects wouldn't be possible. Fellowship uses it for spectacle, and it did not age well.
>b-but muh elves at Helm's Deep
not a flaw. it helps Theoden's character arc, reminds the audience about Aragorn's connection to the elves, and the deaths help bolster why the elves can't/won't send more help later in the series. the only argument against it is "it's different from the books" which isn't an argument, and nobody cares when Fellowship deviated from the books.
Nathan Jenkins
Nothing, Two Towers is the best of the 3. It has the epic story of 3 while still being down to earth and personable like 1
James Rogers
Extended or theatrical?
Carson Jackson
>Elves at helms deep
>Aragorn takeout death
>Osgiliath detour/plot cul-de-sac
>Shield skateboard
>No Shelob climax
>No "Frodo has been captured" cliff hanger
Jose Peterson
Niggers.