They were cinematic masterpieces but Jackson already had ruined the lore with awful an unnecessary changes.
>no Celeborn
>no Annatar
>no fall of Eregion
>No fall of Numenor mentioned
>no death of GilGalad (at least they made storyboards)
>no Old Man Willow
>No wraiths and the barrowdowns
>no Tom Bombadil
>no Ingor Inglorion
>no Glorfindel (replaced by Arwen)
>no Saruman's white wolves
>elves in Hornburg
>Frodo reaching Osgiliath
>Faramir being a jerk
>no Halbarad and Grey company
>no Elrond sons
>no primitive men helping the Rohirrim
>no mention of Rivendell, Lothlorien and Mirkwood attacked
>no mention of the war in Dale with dwarves and elves helping men
>no scourging of the shire
and many more, then he did the Hobbit turds with even more fucked up changes.
So the Rings of Power only continues Jackson's fanfiction.
They were cinematic masterpieces but Jackson already had ruined the lore with awful an unnecessary changes
Other urls found in this thread:
Cutting things out is far, far preferable to changing things.
>No pedantic useless details added to the plot
Oh no if only we ruined the only 10/10 movie in the trilogy by confusing everyone with lengthy scenes of a fat singing man deus ex machina saving the protagonists multiple times and not advancing the plot so it runs for 4 and a half hours.
RoP(e) apologists are lower than dogs
Books are by nature way easier to write fantastic scenarios and plots than fantasy films are to make, the uncut lotr films are already massive, you can't perfectly translate a book to the screen and it's retarded to do so.
I love the seethe of the LotR fags. Yes your gay little fairytale is ruined lmao.
they definitely needed to make it an eight-movie series so we could have the entire second movie be a musical called Tom-Bom-Ba-DILLO!
wow bastard
Yes, at least six movies of three hours each
First one woud have an extended Dagorlad battle and Celeborn in Eregior, it would follow the Hobbits until Rivendell
Second include kazad dun, Lothlorien and until Boromir death
Third would be the weakest one, maybe ending with Faramir attacking the moors
4 until Helms Deep and Shelob
5 would have Pelargir Cirith Ungol and minas thirith until thr Peleannor fields victory
6 would have some numenor flashback, the black gate battle, the volcano and the scourging of the shire and ending
Don't care, you just made this thread to distract from how awful ROP(e) is.
Ironically LotR would work extremely well as an episodic show because each chapter is pretty contained and they could have adapted the book basically 1:1 but instead we get some second age fanfic without the rights to any of the stories portrayed
>no Celeborn
He was in the movies tho, even if Galadriel got all the attention.
Jeff, people still shitting on your shit tier product.
I meant Celebrimbor
Teleporno
>ruined the lore
Bookniggers need to fuck off. Jackson turned some autistic gigawiki into masterpieces.
Christopher tolkien hated the movies
Its pretty good zoomer
Christopher Tolkien let Amazon shit all over his father's legacy
>no mention of the war in Dale with dwarves and elves helping men
youtu.be
You can only go so far when adapting books of such scale into movies. Dunc also has a lot of things missing or butchered but it's probably as good as we are gonna get as far as Dune adaptations go
>>no Celeborn
What the fuck are you talking about? Already retarded on the first try.
I don't think Christopher Tolkien ever watch this for a second.
Here’s that source material accurate lore concerned fan I was telling you about
This the source material was stupid anyway nobody even liked it