How did Tolkien get away with this Gary Stu?

How did Tolkien get away with this Gary Stu?

Attached: samwise-gamgee-wedding.jpg (960x404, 59.64K)

Stop trying. You are a failure.

>Gary Stu
Dude, he was the equivalent of the male childhood friend from every hentai except instead of getting cucked he married the town slut

so a gary stu then

I don’t remember aragorn, legolas, etc even acknowledging his existence

>has one good thing happen to him
>gary stu

bro he lost his best friend in the world for a larger house, everything else he got from work.

sam never failed at anything ever, he was literally incorruptible for no reason

Aragorn told him his horse Bill would find his way home. Also got him back on his feet after Gandalf's "death."

>This is Bill, lord of all horses

how is samwise a gary stu he is supposed to be a simpleton

All of Tolkien's good guy characters are gary stu's

>gary stu
>scared to leave his hometown and only left because Frodo convinced him

Attached: lor.gif (500x206, 47.1K)

>static gif
>lor
Die you fool

that's not the definition of a mary sue, you dumb cunt.
and he only had the ring for like 5 minutes.

if rey is a mary sue then so is sam

Rey broke and shattered force boundaries out of nowhere

how is Sam anywhere the same... he's simply a great man with loyalty working as both strength and weakness

he made him likable

It was the 60s. It was a dark time for literature and Tropes weren't really called out

sam can fly a spaceship?

sam is made the literal GREATEST man, with even more immunity to the ring than Frodo, with no character flaws and he is always right

>I can't carry it for you... but I can carry you.
i cri evrytiem
brave little fat hobbit

Attached: 1659821173793215.jpg (334x506, 29.4K)

>and he is always right
The first thing he does in fellowship is help merry and pippin get frodo stabbed by cooking in the middle of the night.
He bitches and moans for the first movie without achieving anything, almost drowns towards the end.
He grows during the movies, and at the end he is much more experienced, but he's far from "always right"

one day

you dont know why

>has lived in the shire his whole life sheltered from any danger
>survives all kinds of monsters, giant spiders, sauron's goons, etc...

>not a gary stu