RoP is an absolute disgrace to Tolkiens name...

RoP is an absolute disgrace to Tolkiens name, this on the other hand is how you make a fully formed adaptation of Tolkien's vision and inventiveness.

Attached: bridge.webm (900x504, 1.27M)

Yeah...ok...but one thing tho?
Where are the disabled folk? Fucking ableist fuck writers, diversify those fucking hobbits with a peg leg or something.

People keep bringing this as a counter-argument as if the Hobbit wasn't considered a giga turd.

Attached: 1644966458117.png (600x692, 381.47K)

cringe, that's about as funny as saying "my pronounce are fuck you". chuds can't into funny ever.

two wrongs don't make a right

because the backlash was never "this isn't Canon! this isn't Tolkien!", the backlash was because the film was too long and the story didn't warrant 3 films. honestly I don't remember there being half as many Tolkien scholars on this board but today its like every other rings of power post is some claim to authority regarding the mythology

No one likes the hobbit trilogy amd the third one was the worst of them.

go back to r eddit

literally the only white person who ever said anything bad about the hobbit movies was lindsay ellis, and Any Forumstards hate her

people bring it up because this film was judged on its merits and not BS arguments like it's not faithful to Tolkien etc even though it's a bigger offender in every single category.

were you even alive when Any Forums had a meltdown about there being two black extras in the second hobbit movie.
How it was completely unrealistic for nogs from far harad to make it that far north

The female elf that fell in love with the dwarf was totally made up for those films. That scene with them discussing sauron and sauroman goes to check it out wasn't in there either. People complained about those

The only Hobbit movie that matters

Attached: hobbitmovie.jpg (1920x1080, 409.32K)

The amazon series isn't even based on a source, it's just using the name "lord of the rings" while the using the names of some of Tolkien characters, while not acting like those characters. It's in every way worse

i liked this

Attached: bigbenis.png (1863x824, 985.89K)

it's using the appendices at the end of ROTK and Tolkien didn't go into great detail about any of the events and characters involved (you'd have to go into christopher tolkien's stuff for that)

>the backlash was because the film was too long and the story didn't warrant 3 films
The backlash goes way beyond that.
Not like it matters, if people didn't like the movies there's no point in bringing them up because they weren't liked.

It's not like RoP issues are exclusively "not Tolkien's vision!" or whatever, anyways.

It was bad on every level. What they did to Radagast alone is unforgivable.

Im pretty sure the backlash trashing it for turning it into lame capeshit is implicitly saying its not faithful to tolkien

No one considers the Hobbit to be good. Other shitty adaptations existing doesn't excuse RoP for being trash.

The fuck are talking about? People shat all over the hobbit for doing things that was not canonical.

I mean yes yes "multiple things can be bad!" but seriously, nobody can think Galadriel's troll-fighting acrobatics hold a candle to this. This has to be the absolute low-water mark for Tolkien action being interpreted as complete cartoonishness.

Animated Second Age show when?

That would be the dwarves in the river or misty mountains.

>worst parts of the mediocre hobbit movies are about as bad as RoPe

It was cool. As long as you do it in small doses, seeing a fully decked-out Dark Lord Sauron is great.

This scene was simply to show elves are light and graceful. I don't understand why it's panned so much. If it was the dwarf then ok.

Shit, I just remembered the dwarves riding little metal boats down rivers of molten metal like it was nothing in DoS. That series has more hollywood action nonsense than I initially remembered.

didn't legolass fight upside down?

Galadriel's is worse. The way she waits for her male comrades to try and fail, the excessive camera cuts, the way she dodge rolls like its a fucking videogame and the way she spends half of the fight with her back turned to the troll twirling her sword and mugging for the camera.

The jackson thing was a stunt idea he had that was executed poorly meanwhile the galadriel thing couldn't have been good if even if it was done perfectly because the whole choreography of the fight is piss poor

why don't you trannies just admit you're only defending ROP because the 'incels' hate it?

rop and this scene are both absolute shit. also your rop generals read completely differently from every other thread on the board