unironically they should include this scene in the final cut
it gives more info why the empire is actually evil, because they want to nationalize private business
and more emotional attachment to lost of his friend in the battle
Unironically they should include this scene in the final cut
Angel Parker
Other urls found in this thread:
Brandon Moore
The deleted scenes in the OT always feel so weird. This is a good scene but pretty slow. It may have worked. I'd liked to have seen Luke in the skyhopper at some point
Liam Wilson
too much people talking
where's the space swords and the laser guns?
Oliver Kelly
>your uncle could hold off a whole colony of sandpeople with one blaster
Did he forget when Luke's grandma was kidnapped and raped to death?
Oliver Ramirez
back in the 70s when side character sci-fi men could just be regular well adjusted guys, if this was made now he'd be a victim of sexual abuse and would have gay feelings for Skywalker, he's make sure to mention "THE MEN who run the empire" also he'd be a nigger
Daniel Butler
martha saved star wars
Andrew Morgan
no
they were garbage
star wars was saved in editing by marcia lucas
she cut that trash form the movie and that's a good thing.
Aiden Mitchell
kys
Adrian Lee
>The deleted scenes in the OT always feel so weird.
Most of them were cut for good reason.
>This is a good scene but pretty slow. It may have worked. I'd liked to have seen Luke in the skyhopper at some point
I think Mark Hamill's acting is particularly bad in this scene and it adds nothing besides the Biggs subplot which I was fine being cut. We get enough of what Luke is.
It is like how the RotJ Luke building his lightsabre scene has been shared a bunch and is doing the rounds again. And for me it weakens his reveal later on. Most of these scenes were clunky.
Asher Long
agree
thats because they are rough cuts with provisional voice and sounds
you are a fucking npc
and btw all movies are "saved by the edit" you fucking retard
Brandon Anderson
how come she didnt become the best editor in the industry then?
Benjamin Roberts
a couple over the shoulder closeups, some ambient noises, a few dinosaurs in the background, and a little of Luke's melancholy leitmotif and the scene would be fine.
Ian Hernandez
Kek, retard. Marcia Lucas wanted these scenes included and George basically overruled her.
Jason Hall
>Most of them were cut for good reason.
this is such a corporatist opinion
"le final product I saw was the better one"
fucking sad
Ayden Price
>I think Mark Hamill's acting is particularly bad in this scene and it adds nothing besides the Biggs subplot which I was fine being cut. We get enough of what Luke is
his act is very natural and comfy, very relatable.
And it explains what the empire is doing ans how many rebels come from the imperial acadamies themselves, its a very nice worldbuilding and it shows the humane part of Tatooine.
Also the girl was cute.
Joseph Long
I agree. It makes no sense to have Biggs show up and die as if we're supposed to give a shit. You don't need more than a couple minutes to introduce him and then have him fuck off. He's a vehicle for Luke - not a character - but that doesn't mean his sudden appearance and death isn't jarring.
Dylan Thompson
no, Brian De Palma changed Star Wars
Josiah Murphy
george tanked her career over something that was essentially his fault
Cooper Wright
also gold leader knowing Anakin, woiudve been great
Eli Carter
This is a strawman. You can think scenes are clunky in terms of pacing etc for your own reasons. Having disparate scenes not fitting can be an issue. There are films where directors cuts or deleted scenes would have helped.
I think that specific scene felt out of place and wasn't needed. Feels a bit too teenage drama-y in a film that didn't need that.
Brody Robinson
unironically they should include this scene in the final cut
Anthony Nelson
you can say they are clunky without the music ans the edit
Anthony Johnson
It's odd how stylistically different this is from the rest of the film. Nearly any dialogue scene in the film is made up of fairly fast editing between closeups and medium shots, yet there's very little editing going on here. I wouldn't be surprised if they also shot a bunch of closeups for this scene, but they decided to remove the scene before they ever edited those additional shots into these master takes.
Liam Hughes
these scenes were filmed at first
Charles Wilson
So?
Nicholas Anderson
According to the official making of book, the first scenes that were shot are those that take place in Luke's homestead, so you are mistaken.
Ryan Martin
I did like some of the deleted scenes in ESB. The wampa subplot was kinda fun and showing General Veers get kamimazed and die was good. He just disappears otherwise. The Luke and Leia sex scene though, while hot, didn't add much