Why didn't Elrond push Isildur Into Mount Doom again?
ITT: Plot holes in good movies
Evan Campbell
Elijah Gray
Elves fear the Numenorean.
Gabriel Baker
In order to balance their emence power elves have to be useless in most situations
Ryder Ward
It would have started the age of Men raping Elves(male)
Xavier Thompson
Because that would be antisemitic
Austin White
Isildur was handling the one ring™.
Adam Murphy
Isildur is actually his nephew
Christian Miller
Because Isildur was a big guy for Elrond, there was no way he could overpower him.
Nicholas Green
basado
Nolan Gonzalez
Lincoln Fisher
>destroyed the ring
>never destroyed the true threat Grond
Carson Perez
He was a good friend.
Julian Jackson
1) They are related
2) It's a fellow king you honorless dog
3) His army wouldn't have taken it nicely
Gabriel King
Reminder that God pushed Gollum into the lava.
Lincoln Hernandez
How the hell were Numenorean's such chads they could make Elves piss their pants at the thought of fighting them, but then get killed like punks by a bunch of Orcs. Chad Isildur with the one ring gets killed by a bunch of random low level ORCS?! Are you kidding me, Tolkien?
Owen Roberts
The weak gang up on and bully the strong. It has always been this way.
Nicholas Allen
A. They were friends
B. It would have kick-started another war. Do you think Isildur's men would have just taken "he wanted to keep the ring" as a valid excuse to having their king murdered?
Thomas Taylor
Considering isildur is part of his family I doubt he would do it
Parker Brooks
Isildur was are a muttmeronean, the real chads sunk witht he city
Eli Morris
Jackson is a hack, book doesn't have this scene
Jordan Harris
>the real chads sunk witht he city
Wrong. The real chads were about to usurp the Valar and the pussy Elves in Valinor so Eru makes rocks fall and everyone died.
Parker Peterson
>It would have kick-started another war
I'm pretty sure conflict with mere humans is better than returning of Evil Dark lord