The Great Debate

The Great Debate

Attached: snw-vs-orville.png (800x995, 1.28M)

This thread again? Don't you ever have any new ideas? What are you doing with your life?

Debating.

I stopped watching NuTrek a couple of years ago after the first season of Picard and I refuse to subject myself to any more of it so the Orville wins by default.

I haven't seen SNW yet but I'm really enjoying New Horizons

Strange New Worlds is a better show made by worse people. That's the God's honest truth. The Orville means well, but it's just not good and that gave nuTrek the opportunity to at least make one decent, sincere show and dab all over The Boreville.

Attached: 1650152238541.png (1920x960, 1.6M)

Was raped the Star Trek franchise for 6 seasons across 2 shows all part of NuTrek's plan?

Same. Orville at least is watchable, you can foresee a development if being optmistic. Star Trek is made with contempt for the source material, and there is no way around that.

why did they just let this guy get transformed? Why didn't they freeze him to slow the transformation and find a cure?

Why did they fly into the giant evil looking alien butthole in the first place with no protection when they were just warned by the Krill that there were evil ayys that would try to kill them?
>hur dur we're explorers
Fuck off, show.

Attached: 1649112956288.png (1920x960, 1.41M)

They scanned with their sensors, and it looked clean. They're potentially about to meet someone that is already there. The Krill are religious nuts. "Evil looking" is culturally relative.

There were no life signs

Attached: af424cbaeaa4750872cf767f8518969d4edb66dd.gif (445x305, 2.05M)

>Evil looking" is culturally relative.
it looked like Sauron's anus

You're watching the wrong porn user.

What a cope. They were literally warned about supernatural aka not-conventionally-living things that would harm them. They encounter Evil McSpookyship and then bumble their way through all manner of danger while they put two-and-two together Scooby Doo style along the way
>hey, maybe these aren't conventional lifeforms and that's what the Krill meant

The Orville is not a good Star Trek alternative. It's fucking dumb.

There's no such thing as the supernatural. No demons, ghosts, leprechauns, or werewolves.

I would be surprised if there is any Star Trek series that doesn't include an episode about bringing a contagion back from a mission.

Samefag.

This is actually pretty accurate. Orville dicked around for too long and Seth obviously has no real interest in the setting as shown by his lackluster world-building. It gave Paramount enough time to course-correct and actually start making Star Trek again.

Attached: ChrisPike.jpg (779x575, 123.11K)

Watch the episode, numbnuts. They were supernatural from the perspective of the Krill then the crew was like Science! while literally doing everything wrong and stupidly the entire episode.

Retard

Attached: screencap.jpg (547x158, 21.18K)

>It gave Paramount enough time to course-correct and actually start making Star Trek again.
Make it for who now that STD and Picard have driven off a sizeable chunk of the audience?

> one is pure scifi
>one is subversive satire

wow exactly the same! I'm American!

For me. I stopped watching nuTrek halfway through STD S1, watched some Picard, but otherwise dropped it. I hated it. But I think noping the fuck out actually meant Im not giga triggered by a lot of it, either. It's not Star Trek yet but it's a good show.

SNW could fuck up at any moment but they've been knocking it out of the park the past few weeks. Last week's crinkly forehead aliens were exactly what I would expect TNG "aliens" of the week to look like this many decades later. It's not perfect and they need to fix some things but it's growing on me more every week. I even have sympathy for the black doctor guy who was in DUNC. I was weary of the "character arcs" at the beginning but this dude is making me feel his pain. Slays with a fucking look while Seth McFarlane and J. Lee on The Orville couldn't act if their lives depended on it.

Attached: 1645318915492.png (1324x792, 1.26M)

I would rather watch TOS on repeat forever than another episode of nutrek. I know trek has always been progressive in nature but the new stuff is get woke go broke level.

both suck