A non-shill thread

5 minutes into episode 2 they're planning to save a primitive civilization from a comet without discussing or even considering the moral implications (star trek's "prime directive").
Instead everyone discusses their feelings and is a neurotic (i.e. jewish) mess.
Star Trek is about the conflict between morality, feelings and duty.
new "trek" is about feelings, and ideas of morality or duty don't enter into it.
don't spend a single moment on this fucking trash. don't even pirate it.

Attached: header-snw-char-posters.jpg (1100x700, 123.63K)

>the black woman with a black hairstyle saves the world with black african singing
Star Trek is dead.

maybe watch more than 5 minutes. they talk about it for great length.
hell the episode ends with moral teaching about it

This is in the early days of Star Fleet, when rules were still being written/questioned.

>watch more than 5 minutes
nope. never again

Let me sing this old Kenyan song. lalala, God that was cringe.

>This is in the early days of Star Fleet
no it isn't

I give the episode 7/10 even with the black people stuff. Hopefully they'll do an episode with a nod to Nordic people and culture.

this shit is soo fucking bad, horrible acting a even worse acting.

>I give the episode 7/10 even with the black people stuff
lost

no, this is star trek not lost

What's with people who never watch star trek always talking about the prime directive?

No they fucking don't. No one mentions that saving a primitive people from a planet killer comet is a direct violation of orders.

This

The first fucking episode deals with violating the prime directive...it is brought up at least twice, once before beaming down and then again by the XO during the rescue.

Nice try, shill.
You don't need to eat a turd sandwich to know it tastes like shit.

1. The Prime Directive is a law, not morality. Morality counsels in favor of saving innocent sentient beings who are in danger and unable to save themselves.
2. The Prime Directive ultimately had no application to the Kiley 279 situation because the Kiley aliens were already aware of aliens, having seen Federation and Kelpian ships and warp shit through telescopes.
3. A later TOS episode, A Piece of the Action, establishes that it is NOT a violation of the Prime Directive to have contact with a pre-warp civilization so as to remedy harm caused by prior contact. In this case, the prior harm was witnessing warp shit through telescopes and one side in a planetary world war developing a warp bomb.

Learn lore, lorelet. Absolutely nothing Pike did violated General Order One as it existed in the late 2200s. It was the exact same thing Kirk did in A Piece of the Action.

>oh no Uhura and M'Benga are black
>how could they do this to me
Uhura and M'Benga have been black since the 60s, bro. And they were never not black.

Kiley 279 was episode 1. OP is talking episode 2. In episode 2 they didn't give a shit about the PD.

>No they fucking don't. No one mentions that saving a primitive people from a planet killer comet is a direct violation of orders.
they mention is multiple times and was pondered about in the end if it was something they should've done or predestined course of action. did you even watch the episode?

it doesnt really matter. violating the prime directive with the first 20% of the season is a bad move

Within the first 60 seconds of learning about the comet's trajectory they're talking about moving the comet without even mentioning the prime directive...

The Prime Directive had absolutely no application to Children of the Comet because there was absolutely no contact between the Enterprise and primitive people. Saving primitives from existential harm like comets and asteroids is entirely legal under General Order One in the 2200s. See TOS: The Paradise Syndrome (same exact situation).

Plenty of other situations where primitives were saved from existential and unnatural threats in TOS. See, e.g., Return of the Archons (primitives saved from dictatorial computer) and The Apple (same). Cf. The Omega Glory (Kirk aids primitive alien QAnon retards by explaining to them what the United States Constitution actually says).

In each of the episodes you're using to justify the SNW episode 2 bullshit the people of those planets were already contaminated.