Do you think JRR Tolkien would appreciate Avatar The Last Airbender?

Do you think JRR Tolkien would appreciate Avatar The Last Airbender?

Attached: jrr-tolkien-9508428-1-402.jpg (1200x1200, 145.02K)

Aang learned to master senju mode at the end of the matrix

Yes,the real question is would he appreciate goblin waifus

No, because he was a Catholic and the premises of Avatar are incompatible with that.

Tolkien would probably appreciate all creative works.

No Tolkein would shit himself over it's inconsistent use of naming conventions.

Doubtful.

Yes, especially if he's aware it's for children

Kek, this.

I can 100% picture him saying "No, you faggots, you're getting the vowels all wrong." Then in a fit of autistic power he'd write an original language for all of the Four Nations, then he'd write hundreds of pages of commentary on how those languages evolved and what their origins were.

no, he would enjoy hilda

Attached: 100 percent mad.png (959x887, 55.82K)

Tolkien was a very lenient kind of catholic, he had lesbian and gay friends who he was fine with. He had a bigger problem with people who comitted adultery, divorced, or was into socialism (I think?).

Tolkien would like anything, so long as it wasn't written by an Anglican

He wouldn't have liked that all the nations same language.

Better question is; What would Avatar be like and what would change if it was written by Tolkien?

On the other hand, he supported Franco and the Nationalists in Spain.

He didn't like Disney stuff so I don't think he was too big on cartoons

entire episode dedicated to the description of Aang's glacier prison

>"OI, JRR, FANCY THIS AVATAR MATE."
>"NO IS NOT ENOUGH URTHS IS IT NOW THEN."
>"RIGHT RIGHT JRR."

Barely, only on religious grounds since the Republicans were killing priests and he was raised by one

Yeah didn't Tolkien fucking hate Disney?

This is bait

At least the lore would have been consistent.

He was his own flavor of catholic, my favorite one is that during his life the Catholic church changed the rules so that Mass could be said in local languages rather than Latin and Tolkien hated this so much he personally always said the prayers in Latin even while the rest of the room was speaking English

his biggest issue is that he's anti-industry, its rather clear in the work but he's also quite literal about it, he doesn't think industrialization improved society, which fits with him liking Avatar, after all the villains are the ones using industry just like in LotR

Franco and the nationalists were more popular than the socialists with artists around the world in those days (the socialists had a lot of suport worldwide too specialy among american artists), salvador dali supported franco too.

>Then in a fit of autistic power he'd write an original language for all of the Four Nations, then he'd write hundreds of pages of commentary on how those languages evolved and what their origins were.
Yep, that's Tolkien alright.

Snow White stepped on one of his and CS Lewis' pet peeves, the infantilization of fairy tales and especially Fair Folk.
They both praised the actual animation, Tolkien going so far as to muse that it would be the ideal medium to adapt his works.

his problems with disney are more complex than cartoons bad, Tolkien was a literal expert on fairy tales so his problems with disney are more like going into detailed specifics about how the movies adapted the stories.

It's also worth pointing out that Lewis was an Irishman in a time where the Irish still largely believed in the "Good People". He probably didn't want to upset them.

Imagine if it got the Legend of Galactic Heroes OVA treatment

He'd probably think it was okay for what it was but also find the Aristotelian elements magic system a little hackneyed.

>lenient
He literally autistically shouted archaic Latin in mass when they changed the liturgy to vernacular language.