Which is better: Old or new Metallica? Discuss.
Papa Het or James?
Nathan Morgan
Jackson Walker
>mehgduhglickka \m/
Chase Hughes
GIMMA FUE GIMMA FIE GIMMA JABBADABBAZIE
Carter Evans
DON'T TREAD ON ME era was best
Grayson Ramirez
user, I was around when they cut their hair and their fanbase went absolutely ballistic over how their homogods looked. Style over substance in the extreme. Metallica fans should be embarrassed of themselves.
Noah Powell
Is this even a discussion
Benjamin Cook
>popular = bad
Ryder Williams
Very few bands become better once they age up and mature, and I don't think Metallica is an exception to that rule.
>Style over substance in the extreme
They also completely switched genres of music. I'm 30 so I wasn't heavily into music when that shit happened enough to care, but I still understand why people freaked over Load/Relod because they're fucking Southern rock albums.
>b-but people need to be more open minded about genre
No they don't, people can like whatever they want and dislike whatever they want
Ian Jenkins
Load and reload should be been 1 album titled The Big Load
Elijah Cox
EET FUK era is peak
Angel Sanders
The Brotherload
Chase Cruz
The White Hot Load
Hunter Hill
How could you call new metallica better in any context?
Samuel Rogers
When are they going to make Unfourgiven?
Owen Martin
For me, it’s Metlica
Luis Price
It's louder
David Ross
I TAKE THIS KEY, AND I STICK IT IN ONCE MORE
BECAUSE YOU'RE UNFORGIVEN...PART 4
Zachary Young
Maybe if you compare it with itself. Death Magnetic was a significant step up from St Anger. But it still has some issues and it couldnt capture the essence of old metallica.
Isaac Butler
Hetfield is a god
Nathan Foster
Hetfield is my hero
Henry Gray
>>b-but people need to be more open minded about genre
Who are you quoting here? Because it doesn't look like anyone said that. Oh dear... user, you wouldn't be making up quotes to argue with would you? Because that is REALLY gay.
Ethan Thomas
>I'm 30 so I wasn't heavily into music when that shit happened enough to care
You were literally a baby when that happened
Owen Long
Keep up guys
Hudson Nguyen
Pozzed Load
Jack Mitchell
Eh, its a toss up. James had that period of deep, dark reflection and made some really good tunes later on, (prior to st. anger, when i stopped listening) but he lost some of his machismo and hormonal rage that gave his songs the gusto.
They were always talented, but until justice for all it was like a group of virtuouso's were snorting bath salts and somehow playing a blitzkreig while in a berserker rage.
His later stuff felt more like a dirge, it still had that power to it but it was kinna like the coals left over from the fire, they burn hotter but the fires already gone out.
David Morgan
This one.