Welcome, Guest
Log In
Sign Up

Video Games #6105

Threads
Video Games
Archives
Home

Post some cool games with less than 500 reviews

GTA VI is taking almost a decade to release

Post games that you're a big fan of despite never having played them

Games Aren't Games

What went wrong?

MAFIA 4 CONFIRMED

ATTENTION user!! I AM YOU FROM THE FUTURE

You're telling me this guy is a virgin?

How come Spider-Man is the only superhero that actually gets games, games that range from mediocre to good

Just picked this up at a thrift store for $2. What am I in for?

Game can be cheesed out with it's main gimmick

Post books and the studio you want to adapt them

Thoughts of this romhack?

What went wrong? Will it ever come back?

ITT: Meaningless buzzwords

What if Hunt Down the Freeman was good?

I don't get "it". Any Forums told me to play it and I just don't see "it"

Why hasn't any other company made a gacha game with the same quality as Genshin Impact yet?

I'm so glad Harley Quinn's finally being desexualized

Why is this bitch such a retard? Why is planeptune full of retards?

Blue Archive Thread

My 'otel's as clean as an elven arse!

Did people complain about Narwa/Ibushi making heavy use of the wirebugs? Because Gorm fucking sucked...

Why do plebs get upset when you spend more money on a hobby?

Nobody really cares about azura despite being a “relevant” character in fates

What's the Any Forumseredict?

Your next child's name will be named after the last character you played as

I want to have a large mixed race family with Petra

The actor who played Alan Wake is Finnish

Have you got anyone you want to call out in the Ultramarines?

Game lets you rent out a girlfriend

Turtles Collection

Memes aside, what's the most dogshit game you've ever played?

Create an area with a unique and interesting weather condition: a rainforest with actual torrential rainfall

WOW, THAT IS RELATABLE

Death Stranding

I reccomend you check out gurumin: a monstruous adventure

Are there any games that take place in Australia?

Why is this version of Zelda so beloved?

Which one do you main?

Is writing for Kotaku harder than making your own game? Indie devs plz respond

Will it ever be topped? The only real flaw I can think of is the difficulty...

Are there any games where the protagonist is a complete and utter pussy?

Why isn't there any adult only MMORPGS with a sex mechanic? Does this not seem like an untapped market?

I went in expecting this to be the worst 3D Mario games...

Don’t you dare buy or even pirate Hogwarts Legacy, CHUDS

Doesn't know himself

Crystal Project NG+ and Randomizer Patch

During/after the events of Kotor 2

Why didn't you faggots tell me how good this was

XIV Island Sanctuaty

All the journos and fans that played it love the game

Armed Fantasia & Penny Blood kickstarter

Why haven't you played Sara's game? It's a great mystery game

We're objectively in a gaming golden age

What's the proper way to react when you destroy a shit talker?

What does Any Forums think of empress’s latest message

You can permanently ruin your save file

Is VR still a meme? Has any company done anything actually interesting with it yet?

Post your face when you die in Noita

Why yes, I'm a console gamer

I will be purchasing this

Will it kill No Man's Sky?

Why are so many ironic weebs drawn to this series?

Steam Deck Thread

Is the best written videogame of the last 25 years in your path

This was official art in a capcom game

Banjo and Kazooie are back in a brand new Vehicle Creation title!

Why does it feel like a job instead of a game?

Cruising through Sikero Shadows Die Twice

You WILL play FFXVI

How hard would it be to get into Starcraft 2 with zero RTS experience?

Video essay review of game

Spend shit tone of time and money getting rights to character

Vidya Husband Thread

I am making a documentary about Black gamers...

Cutscenes can’t be skipped

Floating images that move fast is a horror game to zoomers

How is this guy so based?

How do you feel about permadeath in vidya, is it your preferred difficulty?

Why nobody ever talks about ToP?

My cat is no longer with us

DUNDUN... DUNDUN... DUNDUN-DUNDUN... DUNDUN... DUNDUN-DUNDUN... DUNDUN... DUNDUN... WEELLLLLLLLLLLLLL

What went so wrong?

Castlevania Harmony of Shoes

Will graphics ever be good beyond a time where realistic Ambient Occlusion never existed?

Have you made up your mind yet, my fair-skinned friend?

OH SHIT NIGGA YOU'RE ABOUT TO LAND A CRIT WHAT'S YOUR LINE

Do you ever feel bad having to hurt or kill women in games?

What is the key to making turn based combat fun?

This is Morrowind in 2022.. wow

No new mainline mario game since 2017

How much of Nier: Automata's success can be attributed to 2B's design rather than its real merits as a game like...

You guys lied to me. You told me this was better than Skyrim and Oblivion

What house are you hoping to be apart of?

Why is he a legendary hero of rebellion in half-life 2 when he was just some rando trying to survive in HL1 and nobody...

Multiversus Season 1

Me hitting khezu on the head

Mikan tripped again

Where should I buy Factorio?

Cute vidya boys

I dont get the praise, the levels are boring as fuck...

Destroy All Humans 2

Would you fistbump Neon?

Everything is fine now, GTA-bros

One copy of Animal Crossing: New Horizons, pretty please with sugar on top

When do you think the Switch version of Frontiers will find its way online?

Why do boomers say this is the best Street Fighter when Alpha 3 is better?

Play Persona 4!!!

Reject Kantai Kollection

Wrath of the Lich king fresh

Battle Brothers is a video game

Why didn't they make a third game?

You cannot refute this

I genuinely have less respect for people who do not play video games...

Annette Fire Emblem

Will Project L be the Street Fighter killer?

Stop liking evil women

What's his problem?

Game has licensed cars

Does anyone remember an old PC game from the early 1990s called "Mr. Mix''? It's mainly a typing game...

No open world games with good DEEP combat system, just imagine Skyrim with Mordhau combat

Is this the most overrated game of all time?

Vulpera killed WoW

Why does Nintendo dominate Japan?

Does anyone have a pic of that game?

So ignoring the changes Strive made to the character's story, how does Bridget actually play in Strive...

AMD Ryzen 7000: 5 nm desktop CPUs coming September 27th

"They look like they eat cheese beef bowls."- Toshihiro Nagoshi, CCO of Sega...

I-IS THAT A-A-A-- A LEMMINGS SPACE IN A VIDEO GAME????

Nintendo Direct Predictions

Deck Emotional Support Thread

Armed Fantasia & Penny Blood kickstarter doing well

So much Anti-Trump propaganda in this Spider-Man game

Have you ever fallen in love with a video game character of questionable sexual past?

ITT: female video game characters you like but know nothing about

6.9 on Metacritic

It's just me, idiot

Nintendo fans, is this true?

Is Sims 4 any good?

Shit zoomers say about games

Apparently for the next Elden Ring Patch FROM have been internally testing a new mechanic of disabling the inventory...

Xenoblade Chronicles 3

Please nerf this fucking guy he's literally a hundred times harder than the rest of the game

This game is the devil

Xenoblade 3 bread — Shania edition

A cat game with robots in a dark world? I know what you are talking about

FFVII literally fixed

When you tried Doom for the first time, did you use 3D mods?

What is usually your first upgrade in a game?

Your favorite game gets a Netflix adaption

YOU BITCHES WANT ACTUAL LEGITIMATELY GREAT GAMES!? BACK IT UP, YOU FAGGOTS!

ITT: Moment in video games that made you scream "HOLY FUCKING GAME ESSENCE"

Games with a happy ending? I need some positivity

Hates madden because it's the same game every year

Golden Axe is dead

I liek neco arc

Vidya sisters get the fuck in here!!

Are there any games that have a high amount of game essence to you?

I’ve never played an MMORPG. Is there any out atm worth playing?

How is this allowed?

DeS and DaS1 kinda boring now

Is the best Naruto game ever made in your path

You don't pirate, do you user?

Stop pirating video games, just rent zem already...

Games with this feel?

Stormcloaks really started a civil war over this

This is poised to be one of the biggest flops in history

So Dragonflight is the only hype game coming this year?

Game allows to you hit women

Why are gamers so submissive?

Has anyone ever BTFO themselves so hard before or since?

Buy physical games only

What a fucking retarded minigame holy shit

Denuvo on Nintendo Switch

Sonic adventure: remastered

Should female video game characters wear realistic armor Any Forums?

Name games Any Forums tricked you into playing but turned out shit

What games would you consider "Any Forums core"?

Is Warcraft reforged that bad if I just wanna replay the campaign?

It has come to my attention that Street Fighter 6 has nerfed the women...

What's the best way to enjoy GTA 3 in 2022

What's the appeal of chinese vidya character design?

FFXIV threads should be banned

This is actually fun?

Thoughts on john carmac?

Heres your hat user, enjoy

Post non-ugly female characters from modern games

There will never be anything like this for a long time

Bros... not even Terraria is safe

Animal Crossing vs Stardew Valley

Extremely powerful enemy chases you

POV: You're the next game on the shelf he's gonna choose and play incredibly shitty

OG Pac-Man World Designer Seething at Not Being Credited in Remake

I unno Dutch, the times are changing. I think if a man wants to cut off his pecker, well I think we oughta support that

Street fighter 4

Where is the klonoa video?

This is what Breen could have looked in Episode 3

Unironically the best handheld out there

Classic indie kinos

How did we go from this to this ?

Imagine being transported to the digital world and instead of getting a badass dinosaur or robot or monster you get...

What dead MMO are you currently playing, Any Forums?

Comfy Switch Thread

What do you think of her game?

Guys, Arkworthy here! I thought we could use another deck thread!

How are you not excited for this game?

OHHHHHH SHAAAAAAAAAA

What’s the worst opinion you’ve ever seen on Any Forums?

What killed Senran Kagura?

I feel like battle royales are popular among normies because of the RNG...

Whats the secret to enjoying this game...

Subscribe to GamePass user

Saints Row will flo-

Has Miyazaki become too powerful? Could he now challenge Todd 1v1?

Kanna loves you, Any Forums!

Muscle girls in video games thread

Egirl streamer beats Elden Ring last week with at SL1 while using a single hand with a controller without healing

200 years have elapsed after apocalypse inf a

Is literally the best and the most advanced GTA title that was ever created

Videogames are waste of time

My billion dollar game idea is punch out, but with animals

Which one are you gonna buy ?

Being a twitch streamer sounds like one of the worst "jobs" you could have. Unless you are in the 000...

Peaceful Bridget Thread

ITT: Shit games you got tricked into playing

Tales of Waifus

If they don't release a $400 version it's DOA...

How does Any Forums feel about Sakurai's Youtube channel?

What happened to fun video games ?

You still have yours, right?

Was Momiji made the smallest chested DoA girl in 6?

How do we fix loot in dungeons, Any Forums?

Thoughts on Prey?

Comfy Steam Deck Thread

Main character is an edgy loner

So since there is a sale right now, what are some classic PC titles worth picking up from GOG?

Well Any Forums?

Why were 3’s girls so trash compared to them?

Tfw you are as old as Auron now

Any reccomendations for an Xbox controller I'll be using on my PC

Just make their game an homage to some of their favorite horror media

This game is so underrated

Serval on the front page!

Did you sober up Any Forums? There's still hope for The Firewalker

How do we save Sony? Japan is ready to let PS5-kun die

You didn't beat it

Redpill me on League of Legends lore

This is the only person cracking Denuvo now?

This is a free game

Are you excited about Street Fighter 6?

One Piece is one of the biggest manga/anime in the world but all of its games are shovelware crap. What gives...

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA

Game uses the word "death" or "dead" once

What? no saints row thread? let me fix that

Do Not Play Hogwarts Legacy

Why are zoomers like this?

>This is supposed to be a bat in a videogame

Why did Genesis music sound so much better than SNES music?

Video game cats

It still mogs any of the Assassin's creed games

What the fuck do I play

What did Robert F. Fox mean by this?

Now you remember ro-500 and shimakaze from kancolle

What Vidya character gives you this feel?

Night in the Woods

Chosen one with the HEART of gold destined to save the world from DARKNESS

Name a bad game made by them

Any Forumsidya Drawthread

Castlevania upgraded

HOW THIS GAME IS STILL FUN TODAY

Funny videogames comics thread

Play Genshin Impact

Trolling outside of Any Forums

Is there a single good video game adaption in the history of mankind aside from Arcane?

Weeee I can fly!!!!

So I was playing Oblivion again today when I came across pic related for the first time. Weird...

Which games have the best-feeling guns?

Bloodborne is overrated

Just finished the Selaco demo

Please don't buy Hogwart's Legacy

Post your steam profile

Nobody mains this class

Games you want to play that don't exist

>Hurr durr PS3 has no games

Check upcoming games

Oh my god its still shit

He spent $2000+ on his PC, $200 on the keyboard, $150 on the mouse, and $400 on the monitor

Which game has the highest "game essence"?

Has any other developer coasted on their reputation as long as Kojima...

Hey user, here's your daily reminder that video games are supposed to be fun above all else

A mod that removes pride flags is completely unacceptable and anyone who uploads or downloads such a mod will be banned...

Danamku goes in all fields

Space Channel 5

Let's be honest, this is a great game

I leave Rome for she

Game has character creator

So this is Playstation's answer to Microsoft acquiring Activision

This guy slaps your ass and decides he's going to rape you

NVIDIA is delaying the RTX 40xx series until early 2023 now...

VIDYA WEBM THREAD

When did the super-hero genre become pseudo-stealth genre?

Catch cute steam friend playing lewd game

Does your gamer mouse have hole technology?

Dark short hair is the best female hair (in 2D especially)

Store.steampowered

Bloodbornesisters?? WHATS THIS?? WHY DOES IT LOOK BETTER THAN OUR GEM??

Would you forgive him?

Is there a game where I can kill my enemies and sking them to wear them as a coat as the ancient Irish did?

60 solid hours of game without an open world and without backtracking

The ultimate example of soul vs soulless is the soul of a controller vs the soullessness of a mouse and keyboard

Why aren't you importing all your favorite Japanese games and hardware now? You literally have no excuse

Return to Shiroganasu Island (HER GAME)

Most iconic videogame in decades

This scares and confuses the oldfag

Chuds are upset once again because women aren't being sexualized anymore

PC gaming is for mega autist only

Nintendo has recently been slowly getting out of their comfort zone by making the Mario movie with Illumination...

Even normies realize it's the same shit as before

Have you played BT's game?

What games have robots?

Thoughts on Elden Ring pvp?

Found my old Game Boy and put some batteries in, my Pokémon Red save file from 1999 is still intact. Hello...

Nintendo Direct

What does strive have that other fightans lack to maintain a high playercount...

What are your favorite dystopian games?

Mission begins in 60 seconds

Ty the Tasmanian Tiger turns 20 on Sept. 10

Do you play video games with your gf?

PM’d you the fix ;)

STEAM DECK WILL RECEIVE NEW VERSION/MODEL

Main character of the last game you played has to fight Gold Expierence Requiem, how will he fare?

Now that the poop has settled, is it actually a good videogame?

What's next for Samus?

LaPUTA got an english fantranslation

Post a book you think would make a good game

Why has there been such a large push for energy drinks and "supplements" for gaming?

Will Sorcery be enough to save it?

Why did Ashley, a small young goth girl, overshadow literally every other non-Wario WarioWare character?

Okay, this is epic

Can RWBY save the Metroidvania?

Dying for an ARPG

...How the fuck were you supposed to figure out how to get the Golden Chocobo without a guide?

When did racing games stop being fun

Summerkino Saga

Pass the controller bro

Why does this system cause so much drama on Any Forums? PC gaming has been loved by Any Forums for years...

A Dev tries to pull a RP stunt by claiming that they being review bombed by Steam curators...

Are Japanese character designs problematic?

Ended up buying Metroid Dread. What am I in for?

And a special thanks to You! The Player

When are we getting Sly 5?

It's no masterpiece

I hate the new idols

This piece of shit needs to die already

Has 10+ weapon types

Visual Novels are shi-

Why did fighting games die? It used to be the most popular genre in the 90's

Achievement: Baby Steps (complete the tutorial)

Dot hack thread

How do we revive the hype for dragonball games

Who is your favorite Sonic girl?

Cant buy this thing anywhere so I went on amazon and bought an Xbox

I summon your Any Forumsidya wife!

Why do people here hate MOBA?

What went wrong?

Runescape 3 gets raped by mtx

6 YEAR OLD CONSOLE

What went wrong?

B4B NEW EXPANSION

3 > 2 > 1 > V > PW > 4

Why was Dark Souls 3 such a downgrade Any Forums

Is this really the best combat system Western developers can do?

So they're getting rid of lootboxes and making the game free, which in a vortex sounds great...

This will be a disaster

Any good pirate games?

What is your excuse for not playing Overwatch right now, user?

Comfy jigsaw thread

How could Sega have saved the Dreamcast?

ITT: we write our ideas for a new Tomb Raider game, now that it's currently in development

Are you exited at the posibility of a new LoTR game?

Name 3 (three) upcoming Vidya that unironically look good

For me, it's blood elves

When will the next Scott Pilgrim game release ?

People say this is garbage due to cut content, but what content could actually be added to fix the game...

Has E3 become too big and lost a lot of its impact in the video game industry?

It's been 2 years. Where are all the games with 900 trillion triangles?

Suspicious video game ads

Is it viable now?

AAHAHAHAHAHAHHHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAH

Konami old games on Steam

Here's your Yakuza 6 bro

Why are all the other characters in the game hyper-sexualized except for her...

Best Halo for Multiplayer on MCC?

Redpill me on the Deck

FIVE MONTHS to release

Ladies and gentleman, the new face of Street Fighter

Yakuza / RGG thread

I FUCKING BEAT HIM

What am I in for bros?

Opinion on Roegadyn with female genitalia?

Cancelled games

What's in his bag?

Comfy deck thread

Name 1 (one) competitive online game where you can beat high-level opponents based on creativity and intelligence...

Femhroths not in XIV yet

Earth Defense Force 6

More games should feature love between humans(male) and monsters(female)

Why do gamers do this?

What game has the most broken weapons?

Underrated game

Strauss Was Based

I beat the game

Stealth game has ilfiltrating mission

Name the artists you want game devs to hire for your games

Game is set in ye olde britain

Just installed this. What am I in for?

I'VE BECOME SO NUMB

Are you ready to see MGS2, 3, SH2, SH3, SH4 and Suikoden games on Steam??

I'm Absolutely Sick of the Shit This Game Gets

How do we gatekeep vidya

Bloodborne Definitive Edition

His mouse has a wire

What in the everloving fuck is this design...

Why yes, I am a PC gamer, how could you tell?

What are some crossovers you'd like to see?

Is it worth playing?

Senseless killing good

Name 1 (one) game where your character grows old/gets fat if he eats too much

It's dark out here

The age of piracy is coming to an end

What are the odds that new Monkey Island game flops hard?

Heh, us gamers right?

IS there a game with an actually well written gay character ?

What videogame is it?

HIT 2 - Kiki Gameplay

We can all agree this fat loser will probably create oasis from ready player one irl, right?

I refuse to believe i'm the only one on Any Forums playing this game

HALF LIFE 3 ARTWORKS

Why is FFXIV not a hit after all this clout and years on the lifeline?

TIK TOK REDDITBORNE.. LIES OF P IS COMING

Why is Nintendo allowing this? Are they really powerless to stop emulation?

I never knew there was a cowboy-themed edition of EuroTruck Simulator

3 years inside a maximum security prison. You get one video game (no games that require an internet connection)

This guy is a fucking retard

Destroy All Humans! 2 - Reprobed CENSORED AGAIN

Yes i play on console, how did you know?

Tfw accidentally taunt

Warhammer Games

Quit screwing around

On a scale from 1 to hype, how hype are you for SFVI?

Would you rather a new star fox or fzero?

Cities Skylines

What do orcs smell like?

Play Japanese game

Post games youve never played but know they are shit due to vibes

The good ending isn't possible to get anymore

ITT: bad game design

Hi, Anthony Burch here. l am a Poz-Kekold. You want to know what that is? Well, let me explain

Hesitation is defeat

Any mario fan parody

Post a game you own and that you're happy

*mogs Zoom Shiternal with one finger*

What is the best fantasy race and why is it dwarf?

Now that the dust has settled are we finally willing to have a conversation about why Elden Ring is actually one of...

Slugcat wishes you a productive day :)

Fucks a man over so hard that he turns into an immortal soulless husk, who's slowly corrupting the entire world

Boyfriend is a huge fan of hearts of iron 4

Melty Blood Type Lumina

THE ROADS ARE THE DUSTIEST

Buy Riko's game

To THIS DAY it (and Gothic 2) is the ONLY Open World RPG where the content is actually unique thorought the map with...

Supbar update sold for $60

Are we witnessing death of the game?

Vidya cat appreciation thread

What are the best "Choose your story" games?

Ayo teach bitch...

I have played the first game at least once every year since its release

The Elder Scrolls 6 composer

Ending of portal 2 makes no sense, America was supposed to be destroyed

What was the first video you ever saw online that was directly video game related? I wanna gauge the age of you fags

Why is there no video game about facesi-

Games been shit for years

Gunfire reborn got a dlc?Thoughts?We got a monkey and a fox girl but personally we need new maps and enemies

What went wrong?

Last online: 4 weeks ago

What the fuck is a movie game?

Why did you stop loving me, nepu?

I thought this board was Any Forums not Any Forums, almost like we need a separate board for tranime games

Motion sickness in gaming

Right-wing gamers be like “females have ruined gaming” and then cog disso booting this up

"what if we made Devil May Cry, but good"

Do game mods ruin the experience?

Who was the best Arkham girl?

Look out! It is the nemesis of the modern western game developer, red meat!

Crpg games with playable non-humans that aren't just the usual?

I like this controller :) does anybody else?

Trucy is the cutest

Forspoken 10 minute gameplay

Steam Deam Thream

Have they made 1 good game?

RTX 3050 or 2060?

What’s the most fun class to play? Grenadier?

This is one of the best MMOs ever made and the grnre is now missing its spiritual replacement

Living the dream

The game wasn't shit, you just played it wrong

I didnt know that Deponia games was so based. Just got this from a friend and surprised me how good it is...

We haven't had a (non-handheld) 1v1 DBZ fighting game since Infinite World 14 years ago

The eternal debate

Remember user, it wasn't a decrepid...

Gabe Greenwald General - /G(abe)GG/

3080ti's down to around $1300 in canada

How do I refuse to join either and get this neutral route I keep hearing about in threads...

What new games have you played?

Post your favourite box art

*slurp* oh, don't mind me. *slurp* I'm just here to *slurp* watch you play video games. *slurp*

Why don't you pay $20 more for early unlocks Any Forums?

ITT what is the hypest possible announcement that could happen at vidya conference (e3, tga, etc) in your opinion?

Are you hanging in there, Any Forums?

Anybody else not like pic related?

Harley Quinn finally looks more realistic instead of the unrealistic sex doll

Gameplay seems very fun. Played the trial

What will Square Enix gift to Embracer next? Are there still any studios they haven't run into to the ground yet?

Why is Zelda such a bitch

Cheat once, 3500 days ago

Is this game any good

If Switch and PC were not an option, would you sooner game on a Series X or PS5?

This is my wife, and she can kick your ass

Hows that Youtube channel coming? along son? Are ya making it?

Justify piracy, Any Forums

Gameplay > audio > graphics >>>>>>> story

Marvel Ultimate Alliance 3

Rogue-like dlc tomorrow

What went wrong?

I don’t know if it’s my depression or if there really isn’t shit for games but after 22 years I’m getting tired...

Knew the ending was coming

What causes even WoWfags who know that the game sucks dicks to still defend it either way against other (better) games...

We went from Professor Oak...to THIS?

Actual Nioh 2 Thread

Have to write 300 word essay due on Tuesday

This IS a guy right?

What is the most underrated Sonic game?

Became a lawyer with 13

The corsair is my favorite RTS unit because it is a dedicated anti air unit...

The most underrated game ever

What was his problem?

You can date literally every npc in the game

Newfag from 2 months ago

Stop right there, Asshole!

Does Jesus Christ no longer have a place in vidya games? I've noticed a lot of people lately dissing the good word...

If anyone has been itching for PlayStation 6 info we won't have to wait for long...

So now that it's literally all but confirmed that we're FINALLY getting a new eeveelution after all these fucking years...

Hey bro lets make 10 characters have their names start with the same syllable, its not like thats strongly discouraged

Is liking videogames still mocked in public?

What worlds do you want to see? The realistic artstyle has me worried that live action Disney movies are in

You know what? I'm going to say it...

Recommend me a groovy game

Adds literally nothing new

You are now reminded of dmetrius96

Thread about farcry5 randomly deleted

Doom 2016 is so much better than Doom Eternal it's not even funny

So what are you guys thinking of Tribal Hunter?

Fuck you it was a good game. GOAT tier OST and was the perfect send off for Kiryu

Is there any upcoming game that you are genuinely excited for?

Honestly, how bad is it

What game fandom acts like this?